My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

558 - Eat the Wrapper

9 snips
Nov 12, 2026
A woman’s disappearance leads investigators through a tangled mystery involving an unauthorized officer accused of targeting women, but her homicide remains unresolved. Then, the bizarre 1928 Bunyan Derby sends nearly 200 runners across Route 66 in a grueling, injury-filled race packed with heat, hunger, spectacle, and a dramatic finish.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

The Chicks Paid For Speaking Up

  • The Chicks’ cancellation after criticizing President Bush reflected a post-9/11 culture that treated dissent as disloyalty.
  • Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark saw the backlash as punishment for women exercising political power publicly.
ANECDOTE

Sherry Orofino Vanished Near The Taconic

  • Sherry Orofino vanished while driving from Queens to Millbrook in February 1987, and her locked Toyota MR2 was found abandoned near the Taconic.
  • Witnesses reported seeing a blonde woman pulled over by an officer, creating the case’s crucial early lead.
ANECDOTE

Sherry’s Body Was Found Near The Reservoir

  • Six months after Sherry disappeared, fishermen found her skeletal remains near the Croton Reservoir, with no determinable cause of death.
  • Investigators already suspected law-enforcement involvement because witnesses had described an officer stopping women along the same roadway.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app