
Catholic Answers Live #12465 Richard Dawkins Shook My Faith – Why Aren’t You Catholic? - Joe Heschmeyer
Nov 19, 2025
Joe Heschmeyer, a dedicated staff apologist and author, shares his insights on navigating crises of faith, sparked by the influential ideas of Richard Dawkins. He tackles the intricate relationship between Jesus and the lineage of David, demystifying how both Mary and Joseph contribute to His title. Heschmeyer also delves into the topic of papal succession, tracing an unbroken line from Peter to the current pope, supported by early church writings. Engaging and informative, he offers reassurance to those struggling with doubt.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Isaiah's 'Alma' And The Virgin Birth
- The Hebrew alma in Isaiah can mean 'maiden' not strictly 'virgin,' but context can imply virginity and the Septuagint renders it as parthenos.
- Matthew quotes the Greek Septuagint prophecy of a virgin birth, so the prediction existed before Christ and aligns with the New Testament account.
Don't Be Swayed By Confident Dismissals
- Do not be intimidated by Richard Dawkins' confident tone; investigate his factual claims before accepting them.
- Read substantive rebuttals and experts like Alister McGrath, John Lennox, and Trent Horn to assess his arguments rigorously.
Books To Counter New Atheism
- Read focused rebuttals to New Atheism to gain solid answers rather than relying on surface-level claims.
- Start with Trent Horn's Answering Atheism, John Lennox, David Bentley Hart, and John DeRosa for measured critiques.













