Catholic Answers Live #12535 How Do We Respond to Pagan Holiday Claims? – Why Aren’t You Catholic? - Tom Nash
Jan 7, 2026
Tom Nash, a theologian and Catholic apologist, tackles accusations that Christmas and Easter are pagan holidays, emphasizing their Christ-centered origins. He explores the nuanced relationship between Catholics and Muslims, defining spiritual brotherhood and its limits. Nash also clarifies the differences between Catholic doctrine and dogma, discusses free will in the context of predestination, and offers resources for those interested in exploring Catholicism further. This lively discussion appeals to both believers and non-believers alike.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Explain The Meaning Of Jesus' Baptism
- Explain Jesus' baptism as identification and initiation of his public ministry, not repentance for sin.
- Use the baptism example to show how sacraments incorporate believers into Christ's saving work.
Answer Claims About Pagan Holidays
- Respond to pagan-origin claims by showing the Christian focus of Christmas and Easter and historical continuity with the early Church.
- Emphasize the Mass as fulfillment of Old Testament sacrifices and central Christian worship.
Baptizing Cultural Practices Toward Christ
- Historical celebrations can be 'baptized' and redirected toward Christ without importing pagan theology.
- Early Church practice and Christ-centered meaning preserve celebrations' legitimacy.
