

Goldwater Nichols: Still fit for purpose?
10 snips Sep 15, 2025
Eliot Cohen, a leading voice in U.S. strategy and history, dives deep into the complexities of the Goldwater-Nichols reforms that reshaped military command. He discusses how these reforms addressed Cold War challenges but may now limit adaptability to modern threats. Cohen emphasizes the critical need to rethink civil-military communication and highlights the Pentagon's influential role in shaping strategy. The conversation explores the historical context of the reforms, leadership dynamics, and the urgency for potential amendments to better navigate today's global conflicts.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Chairman Centralized Military Advice
- Goldwater-Nichols concentrated military advice to the president in the Chairman while placing operational control with combatant commanders.
- This created a single senior military voice but reduced collective advice from the services.
Desert One As Reform Catalyst
- Desert One's failure acted as the tipping point that galvanized reformers toward Goldwater-Nichols.
- The botched Iran rescue highlighted joint coordination problems across services.
Combatant Commanders Empowered
- Goldwater-Nichols strengthened combatant commanders and shifted services to focus on organization and training.
- The Act also mandated joint experience for promotion to flag and general officer ranks.