Rolling Stone Music Now Why Can't Mariah Carey, Oasis, and Phish Get Into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame?
May 6, 2025
This week, writer Andy Greene dives into the controversies surrounding the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Known for his keen insights into music and pop culture, Andy discusses why artists like Mariah Carey and Phish have been left out. He highlights biases in the voting process, the challenges of genre recognition, and the need for more inclusivity. With a humorous take on potential reforms, he advocates for a system that honors diverse contributions, ensuring that deserving musicians finally get their time in the spotlight.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Rock Attitude Bias in Voting
- Rock and Roll Hall of Fame voters often look for "rock attitude" in artists.
- This bias complicates inducting artists like Mariah Carey, whose style is less rock and more pop/R&B.
Phish's Cult Status Limits Induction
- Phish is an enormous band with a devoted fanbase but lacks mainstream hits.
- Their dedicated community divides voters, making induction difficult despite their live performance prowess.
Make a Documentary to Humanize
- For bands like Phish to get Hall of Fame recognition, creating a widely appealing documentary can help.
- Humanizing bands to a broader audience may boost voter awareness and support.