Felix Salmon chats with Paul Collier, renowned author of The Bottom Billion, who specializes in the economics of neglected regions. They discuss how economic decline can be resisted through local empowerment and community initiatives, citing examples from Spain's Basque region and post-reunification Germany. Collier argues for tailored strategies that embrace local strengths rather than overarching national policies. The conversation highlights transformative leadership, historical lessons, and the possibilities for revitalizing struggling economies across the globe.
Regions experiencing economic decline need local empowerment and tailored strategies to effectively address their unique challenges and opportunities.
Competent national leadership can significantly enhance local recovery efforts by investing in infrastructure and fostering supportive environments for community initiatives.
Deep dives
Understanding the Concept of 'Left Behind' Areas
The term 'left behind' describes regions that have experienced significant economic decline and remain stagnant despite being rich in resources and potential. Contrary to the idea of a 'spiky' world with concentrated economic hubs, the concept emphasizes that many areas have diminished significantly due to unfortunate circumstances, like economic downturns or poor leadership. The decline creates a vicious cycle that is difficult to reverse, often exacerbated by social tensions where residents blame each other for failures rather than seeking constructive solutions. This cycle illustrates a new economic paradigm that challenges traditional beliefs about market forces naturally restoring prosperity to these regions.
Examples of Recovery: The Basque Region
The Basque region of Spain serves as a compelling case study of recovery after a severe downturn, initially triggered by the Spanish Civil War and further compounded by industrial collapse. After experiencing a dramatic decline in the mid-20th century, the Basque people initiated grassroots efforts to revitalize their economy, transforming it into one of the most prosperous areas in Spain today. Their success was not reliant on external political leadership, but rather stemmed from local initiatives and a bottom-up approach to economic recovery. This demonstrates that regional agency and empowerment are critical to overcoming adversity and achieving sustained growth.
Devolution of Power and Local Solutions
Effective recovery in left behind regions requires a devolution of power to local communities, allowing for tailored strategies that address specific regional needs. Resources and decision-making must shift from centralized authorities to local entities that understand their unique challenges and opportunities. This approach fosters community collaboration and accountability, leading to innovative solutions tailored to local strengths. For instance, addressing issues like loneliness necessitates grassroots efforts rather than national mandates, as successful interventions are typically most effective at the community level where personal connections are more likely to be established.
The Role of National Leadership in Regional Recovery
While local initiatives are vital, the presence of competent national leadership can significantly enhance the recovery process for struggling regions. Countries like Germany have demonstrated that substantial investment in public infrastructure can bridge economic disparities, especially after reunification efforts that integrated East Germany. A wise and committed national leadership can create a supportive environment for local movements, encouraging the development of regional identities, strengths, and interconnectedness. However, it is essential for foreign influences, particularly from developed nations, to exercise patience and refrain from imposing their models, as the path to progress in different regions is often unique and requires local understanding.
How do you save a region from an economic tailspin? For this Money Talks, Felix Salmon chats with Paul Collier, author of The Bottom Billion and, most recently, Left Behind: A New Economics for Neglected Places. They discuss the economic and political forces that drag countries and regions to the bottom — and how they might be saved. Paul gives examples across time and geography, from Cold War-era Germany to modern-day Africa.
If you enjoy this show, please consider signing up for Slate Plus. Slate Plus members get an ad-free experience across the network and an exclusive bonus mini-episode with every regular episode of Slate Money! You’ll also be supporting the work we do here on Slate Money. Sign up now at slate.com/moneyplus to help support our work.
Podcast production by Jared Downing and Cheyna Roth.