My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 69: Never A Mannequin
Nov 5, 2025
Karen and Georgia dive deep into the mysterious death of Keith Warren, exploring flawed police responses and troubling evidence. They also unravel the chilling case of Riverside serial killer William Suff, discussing victim patterns and his eventual capture. With a mix of humor, personal anecdotes from their tour, and insightful podcast recommendations, they keep the conversation lively. Hear their thoughts on true crime media, including the casting of Zac Efron as Ted Bundy, while sharing heartwarming personal updates in between.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Starstruck By FBI Guests
- Karen and Georgia describe meeting FBI agents at a meet-and-greet during their tour and being starstruck.
- Georgia moved an agent's finger off his ID to verify it, revealing real agents who worked counterterrorism.
Rushed Ruling Can Hide Homicide
- Georgia details procedural failures in Keith Warren's 1986 hanging that led authorities to label it suicide without an autopsy.
- Exhumation and toxicology later found solvent levels inconsistent with suicide, prompting reclassification to undetermined.
Witnesses Who Then Died
- Rodney Kendall and Mark Finley reported cars searching for Keith shortly before his death, and Mark later behaved urgently.
- After sending photos to Keith's mother threatening Mark, he died in a suspicious bike incident one month later.