Colin P. Clarke, Director of Research at The Soufan Group and author of "After the Caliphate," discusses the enduring impact of ISIS despite the loss of its physical territory. He highlights the role of independent radicalization, where disconnected individuals commit acts of terrorism influenced by the group's ideologies. Clarke addresses the alarming resurgence of ISIS, their advanced propaganda tactics, and the necessity for a robust collaboration between governments and tech companies to combat online terrorist threats.
ISIS has adapted to a decentralized model, maintaining influence through propaganda and inspiring lone-wolf attacks despite territorial losses.
The need for a comprehensive U.S. counterterrorism strategy is crucial, addressing both radicalization root causes and collaboration with technology companies.
Deep dives
Understanding the New Orleans Attack
A tragic vehicle attack on New Year's Day in New Orleans highlights the ongoing threat posed by individuals inspired by ISIS. Colin Clark, a security expert, delves into the actions of the assailant, Shamsuddin Jabbar, who not only drove a truck into a crowd but also had links to ISIS, including an ISIS flag and propaganda videos. While investigators labeled the attack as the act of a lone wolf, Clark suggests the attack’s sophistication may indicate deeper connections to ISIS ideology. Jabbar's troubled personal history may have created a pathway for radicalization, demonstrating how personal crises can intersect with extremist motivations.
The Resilience and Evolution of ISIS
ISIS, originally an outgrowth of al-Qaeda in Iraq, has evolved significantly since its inception, maintaining a decentralized franchise model that enables it to persist beyond its territorial losses. Currently, even after the dismantling of its physical caliphate, remnants of the group continue to exist globally, as evidenced by attacks in various countries. Its propaganda capabilities are notable, with tailored messages reaching potential recruits in multiple languages, signifying their continued intent to inspire lone-wolf attacks. The ability of individuals to conduct sophisticated attacks independently is troubling, suggesting that ISIS's influence is still pervasive despite the group's loss of control over a state.
The Need for a Strategic Shift in Counterterrorism
The enduring nature of the ISIS threat calls for a reevaluation of U.S. counterterrorism strategies, which have often been viewed as reactive and military-focused. Experts argue that a grand strategy is necessary, one that goes beyond killing terrorists and addresses the underlying conditions that foster extremism. Moreover, the integration of technology to prevent the spread of extremist propaganda is essential, with partnerships needed between government agencies and tech companies to combat radicalization online. The failure to adapt to the changing landscape of terrorism undermines efforts to prevent attacks and protect citizens, emphasizing the urgency for a more nuanced approach.
Though their physical caliphate has been gone for more than five years, the terrorist organization ISIS has survived—through propaganda, in chatrooms, and as an inspiration and cheerleader for actions like the New Years’ Eve attack in New Orleans.
Want more What Next? Join Slate Plus to unlock full, ad-free access to What Next and all your other favorite Slate podcasts. You can subscribe directly from the What Next show page on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme and Rob Gunther.