The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Dak Prescott & Cowboys UPSET by McCarthy & Vikings on SNF + NFL Week 15 Reaction
Dec 15, 2025
Join former NFL scout John Middlekauff as he dissects the thrilling Week 15 matchup between J.J. McCarthy and the Vikings against Dak Prescott's Cowboys. He highlights McCarthy's impressive growth and connection with his coach and star receiver. John also delves into the Cowboys' defensive woes and George Pickens' lack of effort. He reacts to significant injuries, including Patrick Mahomes' ACL tear, and admits he misjudged the Bears’ resurgence. With insights on player performances, this chat is a must-listen for NFL fans!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
McCarthy's Performance Suggests Real Development
- J.J. McCarthy showed real growth against Dallas, making touch throws and athletic plays that signal NFL starter potential.
- If he repeats this progress into the offseason, the Vikings can reasonably build around him rather than panic-draft.
Be Cautious With Big Receiver Contracts
- If Dallas can't trust current wideouts like George Pickens, avoid heavy long-term contracts and draft defensive help instead.
- Prioritize smart offseason business decisions and target defense in drafts to stabilize the roster.
Mahomes' ACL Has Major Franchise Impact
- Patrick Mahomes' ACL is a major franchise blow even if the Chiefs were already out of playoff contention.
- The injury has wide ripple effects for Kansas City's short-term competitiveness and long-term planning.