Hilary Mantel, the acclaimed author known for her captivating novels about the Tudor court, dives deep into how we perceive history. She challenges us to think critically about the romanticized and often brutal representations of the past. Mantel warns against oversimplified comparisons like those between the English Reformation and Brexit and emphasizes the importance of revisiting untold stories, particularly of women. Throughout her lectures, she reflects on the complex interplay between history, memory, and fiction, urging us to respect the past's strangeness.
Historical portrayals often distort the past, transforming facts into myths that resonate with contemporary values and identities.
Writers of historical fiction must balance accuracy and emotional resonance, ensuring narratives respect complex historical realities while provoking critical thought.
Deep dives
The Nature of Historical Perception
Perceptions of history are shaped by collective memory, often transforming factual events into myths or legends that reflect current values. The process of remembering the past can be emotional, with individuals and societies favoring versions of history that flatter their identity and sense of self. An example is the idealized view of the Tudor era, which overlooks the more complex and less squalid realities of daily life during that time. By highlighting the dignity of historical figures rather than painting them with a brush of squalor, it becomes clear that our images of the past are more about the narratives we construct than the actual experiences of those who lived it.
Historical Fiction's Role
Historical fiction serves an important purpose, as it can invoke thought and challenge preconceived notions about the past. While it may sometimes lean towards nostalgia, there exists a powerful potential for the genre to provoke critical thinking and discomfort rather than mere entertainment. For instance, the comparison of the present with the past allows readers to confront their own values and understand the complex dynamics of societal evolution. Thus, thoughtfully crafted historical fiction does not simply convey an idealized past; it encourages an exploration of the moral ambiguities and varied experiences of people throughout history.
The Responsibility of Historical Narratives
Writers of historical fiction carry the responsibility to present an accurate and nuanced portrayal of the past, avoiding oversimplifications or distortions for contemporary relevance. By engaging deeply with historical evidence, authors can create narratives that honor the complexity of their subjects while remaining accessible to readers. The caution against projecting modern ideals onto historical figures emphasizes the importance of understanding the values and beliefs that shaped their lives. This approach not only enriches the storytelling process but also ensures that those depicted are not reduced to mere abstractions.
Understanding the Human Experience in History
The exploration of historical events often reveals the deeper human experiences and societal frameworks of times long past. For instance, the religious motivations and moral dilemmas faced by figures like Thomas Cromwell reflect the intricate relationship between individual agency and broader historical currents. Writers must assess and channel the ethical frameworks of past societies while acknowledging that our understanding of these values may be inherently flawed. By doing so, both historians and novelists strive to provide a more authentic representation of the past, allowing us to empathize with the struggles of those who lived before us.
How do we construct our pictures of the past, including both truth and myth, asks best-selling author Hilary Mantel. Where do we get our evidence? She warns of two familiar errors: either romanticising the past, or seeing it as a gory horror-show. It is tempting, but often condescending, to seek modern parallels for historical events. "Are we looking into the past, or looking into a mirror?" she asks. "Dead strangers...did not live and die so we could draw lessons from them." Above all, she says, we must all try to respect the past amid all its strangeness and complexity.
Over the course of the lecture series, Dame Hilary discusses the role that history plays in our culture. She asks how we view the past and what our relationship is with the dead.
The programme is recorded in front of an audience at Middle Temple in London, followed by a question and answer session.
The Reith Lectures are chaired by Sue Lawley and produced by Jim Frank.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode