
The Pete Quiñones Show Episode 1300: Why One Country, But Not All Others? w/ Benjamin Boyce
Dec 2, 2025
Benjamin Boyce, a YouTube creator known for his Calmversations channel, shares his intellectual journey from evangelical roots to confronting progressivism. He explores the contrasting identities of nations like Britain and Israel, linking them to American identity issues. Boyce discusses the impact of his experiences at Evergreen State College, the rise of anti-woke sentiment, and the intricacies of the intellectual dark web. He argues for a return to tradition and the importance of local identities, while calling for serious engagement with young men seeking meaningful roles in society.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Faustian Hubris Drives Modern Progressivism
- Boyce links progressive problem-solving hubris to a Faustian, Luciferian Western spirit that both left and right share.
- He argues humility and easing suffering (Catholic charity model) contrasts with hubristic attempts to 'solve' humanity.
Britain And Israel As Identity Test Cases
- Boyce sees Britain and Israel as test cases for reconciling ethno-national identity with modern politics.
- He believes solving England-for-English and Israel-for-Jews myths will guide U.S. identity debates.
Marriage Rules Shaped Western Openness
- Boyce cites Nick Land's idea that cousin-marriage bans shaped Western outgroup openness via Christianity.
- He argues Western individualism and scale create both freedom and alienation from rootedness.





