Episode 1023: Victoria Nuland, Ukraine and Russia w/ Darryl 'Martyrmade' Cooper
Mar 7, 2024
auto_awesome
Exploring Victoria Nuland's resignation and its impact on US foreign policy in Ukraine and Russia, discussing historical connections and leadership transitions. Analyzing high casualties in Ukraine conflict, shifting foreign policy towards China and Russia, and exploring Russia's historical trajectory and challenges. Delving into post-Soviet relations, oligarch influence, ethnic Russian tragedy in Ukraine, and Russia's evolving role on the global stage.
Victoria Nuland's resignation hints at US policy shift towards Russia and Ukraine.
Institutional biases shape US foreign policy towards Russia and China post-Cold War.
Post-Soviet economic exploitation fuels Russian intervention in Ukraine.
Deep dives
Victoria Newland Steps Down as Major Policy Shift Signal
The departure of Victoria Newland, known for her long-lasting influence on US foreign policy despite changing administrations, signals a potential shift in Eastern Europe policy. Newland's resignation from her undersecretary position raises speculation about a new direction in US policy towards Russia and Ukraine. The incoming individual, known for a more pragmatic approach, contrasts Newland's hawkish stance. This shift may indicate a reassessment of US involvement in Eastern Europe.
Influence of Historical Institutional Cultures on US Foreign Policy Approach
The historical context of CIA's Samuel Huntington's assessment of the US experiences with the Soviet Union and China sheds light on the lingering impact of past institutional cultures on foreign policy. The approach towards Russia and China post-Cold War eras reflects ingrained attitudes from World War II intelligence establishment. Differences in the personnel selection for China desk with diplomatic backgrounds and Russian desk with anti-Russian perspectives demonstrate enduring institutional biases.
Implications of Economic Looting in Post-Soviet Era on Russian-Ukrainian Civil Conflicts
The post-Soviet economic looting and power consolidation by oligarchs instigated deep societal resentments, especially among ethnic Russians in Ukraine. The economic exploitation and significant wealth extraction resulted in widespread animosity towards the oligarchic class. The economic upheavals post-Soviet era influenced Russian intervention in Ukraine, driven by historical grievances and geopolitical strategic imperatives. The narrative of ethnic atrocities in Donbass region reflects complex power struggles exacerbated by economic disparities and historical legacies.
Russia's Security Concerns and Negotiation Efforts
Putin's perspective on Western intentions towards Russia, particularly in relation to Ukraine and NATO expansion, highlights Russia's stance on national security. Despite concerns, Putin initially sought peaceful resolutions and participated in negotiation efforts such as the Minsk agreements. Russia's interactions with Ukraine and its handling of requests for annexation demonstrate strategic decisions based on security concerns.
Misjudgments and the Conflict's Escalation
The conflict between Russia and Ukraine revealed miscalculations and escalating tensions. Initial misjudgments about military strategies and outcomes became apparent as the conflict progressed. While Russia initially aimed for peaceful solutions, the evolving situation led to a shift towards acknowledging the conflict as a war. The influence of external actors and decision-making in prolonging the conflict added layers of complexity to the escalation.
Darryl Cooper is the host of the Martyrmade podcast and the co-host of The Unraveling with Jocko Willink.
Darryl joins Pete to talk about the resignation of the undersecretary of state for political affairs, Victoria Nuland, her role in the ongoing Ukraine/Russia conflict, and an overview of the history of Russia and Ukraine since the Cold War ended.
