Alternate Shots with Richard Haass and John Ellis Episode Eight
12 snips
Nov 25, 2025 The conversation delves into the leaked Ukraine peace plan that critics say favors Russia, raising questions about U.S. foreign policy. The hosts discuss the implications of the Afghanistan withdrawal on U.S. credibility and its impact on relations with Taiwan. Tensions between China and Japan add another layer of complexity as they analyze regional dynamics. The episode wraps up with a light-hearted look at the New York Giants' struggles and future prospects in sports.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
One-Sided Ukraine Plan Raises Alarms
- The leaked 28-point Ukraine plan was overwhelmingly one-sided toward Russia and surprised even seasoned observers.
- Richard Haass calls it extraordinary and cautions it would permanently limit Ukrainian defense and sovereignty.
Process Failures Undermine Credibility
- The administration displayed process failures by not vetting the plan internally or with allies before leaking it.
- Haass calls the approach amateurish and says it undermines U.S. credibility and competence.
Allies Worry About U.S. Unpredictability
- Taiwan and other allies grow uneasy when U.S. signals unpredictability on security assurances.
- Haass says uncertainty about future U.S.-China discussions undermines allied confidence.
