Predrag Gruevski, a software developer from the Rust community, and Chris Krycho, known for his work with TypeScript at LinkedIn, dive into the world of semantic versioning. They discuss the complexities and benefits of SemVer, highlighting the need for improved tooling. The conversation touches on common challenges and violations experienced in the Rust ecosystem and how consistent practices can enhance software development. They also consider alternative approaches to manage breaking changes and the importance of community collaboration in refining versioning strategies.
Enhanced tooling is crucial for managing breaking changes in semantic versioning.
Incorporating type influences in versioning requires robust tooling and categorization challenges.
Alternative versioning approaches like Calver can complement semantic versioning for better predictability.
Deep dives
Challenges of Semantic Versioning and Need for Improved Tooling
The podcast episode delves into the challenges and advantages of semantic versioning (Semver) and emphasizes the requirements for enhanced tooling. It discusses the complexity involved in managing breaking changes and the necessity for accurate tools to detect and prevent such alterations. The implementation of effective tooling is highlighted as a crucial factor in maintaining compatibility and reducing the likelihood of unexpected disruptions.
Influence of Types on Versioning Systems
The podcast explores the impact of different types on versioning systems, focusing on languages like TypeScript and their adoption of Semver principles. The discussion delves into the complexities arising from incorporating type-related changes and the challenges in categorizing them within the Semver framework. It emphasizes the need for robust tooling to manage versioning with type influence effectively.
Alternative Approaches to Versioning
The episode introduces alternative approaches to versioning, such as adopting calendar-based versioning (Calver) instead of strict semantic versioning. It considers the use of marketing-driven versioning alongside technical versioning methods to provide a comprehensive view of software releases. The discussion touches on the potential benefits of incorporating calendar-driven release schedules for better predictability and planning.
Balancing Marketing and Technical Aspects in Versioning
The podcast delves into the balancing act between marketing-driven versioning and technically-driven versioning. It highlights the challenges in communicating breaking changes effectively while maintaining a marketing-friendly approach to release cycles. The discussion suggests potential strategies to optimize versioning practices to enhance user understanding and minimize operational disruptions.
The Importance of Clear Communication and Scheduled Releases in LTS Versions
Clear communication and scheduled releases are vital in LTS versions like Ubuntu's 2404 naming convention. LTS provides security patches for a predetermined period, ensuring users understand the commitment. The predictable release schedule aids in planning for upgrades, both internally and externally. This clarity in communication and scheduling fosters trust among users, streamlines feature shipping, and reduces uncertainties in the upgrade process.
The Significance of Forward Compatibility and Dependabot in Versioning
Forward compatibility and tools like Dependabot play key roles in facilitating smoother upgrades. Embracing multiple major versions within a project, as seen in Rust, emphasizes the importance of compatibility. While managing multiple library versions can increase complexity, it offers flexibility in library dependencies. Peer dependencies further enhance compatibility across dependencies, aiding in resolving version conflicts and fostering better software practices across different ecosystems.
Predrag Gruevski and Chris Krycho joined the show to talk about SemVer. We explore the challenges and the advantages of semantic versioning (aka SemVer), the need for improving the tooling around SemVer, where semantic versioning really shines and where it’s needed, Types and SemVer, whether or not there’s a better way, and why it’s not as simple as just opting out.
Retool – The low-code platform for developers to build internal tools — Some of the best teams out there trust Retool…Brex, Coinbase, Plaid, Doordash, LegalGenius, Amazon, Allbirds, Peloton, and so many more – the developers at these teams trust Retool as the platform to build their internal tools. Try it free at retool.com/changelog
ExpressVPN – Stop handing over your personal data to ISPs and other tech giants who mine your activity and sell off your information. Protect yourself with ExpressVPN. Go to ExpressVPN.com/changelog and get three (3) extra months free.
Fly.io – The home of Changelog.com — Deploy your apps and databases close to your users. In minutes you can run your Ruby, Go, Node, Deno, Python, or Elixir app (and databases!) all over the world. No ops required. Learn more at fly.io/changelog and check out the speedrun in their docs.
