Lying serves essential social functions by fostering cohesion and preventing conflict, a behavior present in both humans and animals.
Most people excel at lying but struggle with lie detection, highlighting the cognitive complexities of discerning truth from falsehood.
Deep dives
Origins and Social Functions of Lying
Lying is not exclusive to humans; various animal species engage in deceptive behavior as a survival strategy. For instance, red-bellied squirrels use deception by alarm-calling to mislead other males, protecting their mating opportunities. In humans, lying serves significant social functions, fostering social cohesion and preventing conflict through white lies meant to spare people's feelings. The capacity to lie is deeply intertwined with our social interactions, reinforcing the idea that deception often fulfills necessary roles in human relationships.
Psychological Insights on Lying
Research indicates that individuals who practice lying frequently become skilled at it, while lie detection remains challenging for most. Interestingly, humans tend to be better at constructing lies than identifying them, which may stem from evolutionary advantages linked to competition and social hierarchies. The discrepancy in skills highlights how complex social interactions can be cognitively taxing, complicating efforts to discern truth from falsehood. Additionally, the anxiety typically associated with lying varies, suggesting that those who lie regularly may not exhibit the same physiological responses as novices.
Development of Deceptive Skills in Children and Adults
Children initially lie more as they learn the social norms surrounding deception, with studies showing that roughly 40% of three-year-olds lie, escalating to nearly 100% by age five. This pattern suggests that, while lying behavior increases in childhood, it tends to decrease as individuals age, with older adults often reporting minimal deception. This reversal could stem from a combination of increased honesty and a reduced need for manipulation in close social circles. Adults, particularly in sales or competitive fields, may still navigate lies expertly, highlighting the varying motivations behind deception.
Lying in Communication and Media
The medium through which lies are communicated significantly impacts lie detection accuracy, indicating that radio communication may allow listeners to be better lie detectors compared to visual mediums. Studies show that deception detection tends to improve in contexts where people focus on vocal signals rather than visual cues. Specific word choices and sentence structures can reveal deceit, as liars tend to use fewer personal pronouns and longer sentences characterized by more cognitive processing. This insight reinforces the idea that context and medium are essential in understanding and interpreting deceitful behavior.
For any of you who have ever told a porkie pie, don't worry, this week we hear why we all do it... and discover that deception is actually good for social bonding. From the red squirrels who cry wolf to scare off the competition, to kids who look you in the eye as they tell bare faced lies, this is a behaviour that occurs across all species. And one man who's particularly good at it is Traitors contestant Paul Gorton who reveals he felt absolutely no guilt about his tv trickery. But it seems that while we're masters at telling tall stories, we're terrible at detecting them, because we've all been focusing on completely the wrong cues.
Contributors:
Paul Gorton
Professor Richard Wiseman
Professor Sophie van der Zee
Producer: Marijke Peters
Executive Producer: Alexandra Feachem
A BBC Studios Audio Production
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
