David Butler, a renowned British political scientist famous for his elections expertise, and Baroness Margaret Jay, a former BBC producer and Butler's student, engage in an insightful dialogue. They reminisce about Butler's groundbreaking seminars that redefined media and politics, discussing the evolution of election coverage with the rise of technology. Butler shares fascinating election night stories, while Jay reflects on balancing neutrality in journalism. They delve into the changing class dynamics in British politics and the critical interplay between academia and real-world political practices.
01:23:41
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
question_answer ANECDOTE
On Not Revising Hung Parliament Book
David Butler declined updating his book on hung parliaments, citing better recent work by others.
He acknowledged his writings become outdated quickly in politics due to rapid changes.
question_answer ANECDOTE
Margaret Jay on Student Seminar Days
Margaret Jay reminisced about her nervous student days as a participant in David Butler’s seminar 50 years ago.
She shared the chaotic 1970 election night experience when an unexpected swing changed everything.
question_answer ANECDOTE
Discovery of the Cube Law
David Butler discovered the cube law in 1949, linking votes to seats via a mathematical formula.
This breakthrough launched his career and led to an invitation to meet Winston Churchill for four hours discussing politics.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Dr. David Butler brings his legendary Friday evening Media and Politics seminar to a final conclusion by answering questions instead of asking them. Dr Butler's well-worn armchair was occupied by John Lloyd (of the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism), who assumed the role of the questioner, together with Baroness Margaret Jay, a former student of Dr Butler. Also for the first time in 53 years, the Chatham House Rule did not apply. The last seminar of David Butler was, uniquely, on-the-record. Bringing together journalists and politicians in an Oxford common room was the revolutionary invention of the young don in 1957. Butler introduced the off-the-record rule for the seminars so that the civil service mandarins, leading politicians and journalists could speak freely and share their real life experiences and anecdotes with the audience. This created an extraordinarily intimate ambience in the seminar room. Butler never asked the guest to prepare a talk, as he "only wanted their genius". Among the guests of the seminar series have featured such towering figures of both British public life and media as Tony Benn, Baroness Shirley Williams, David Dimbleby, Alan Rusbridger, and the director-general of the BBC, Mark Thompson - and the names listed here are only some of the guests of the 85-year old Butler's last academic year. In the previous 52 years the seminar has played host to the former Prime Ministers, Harold Wilson, Jim Callaghan, Edward Heath, John Major and Tony Blair As a young don in his twenties, Butler was twice summoned by Winston Churchill. Sir Winston, having forgotten why he had invited Butler, gave his whole 'Blood, Sweat and Tears' speech over dinner. On his second visit, Butler found himself explaining the arithmetic of the upcoming election by using apples and tangerines. Meeting Churchill, whom he had greatly admired, prepared Butler for interacting with all the famous guests of his seminars. "I could not be in awe of anyone's presence since", Butler said on Friday 4th of June. Butler is one of Britain's first and still most renowned psephologists (study and statistical analysis of elections). British television audiences have come to know him as the astute commentator of the BBC's election night programmes from the early 1950's until the year 1979. He is well known for launching the concept of swing in elections and for co-inventing the swingometer, first used on screen in 1959. Butler was involved in authoring or co-authoring every edition of the Nuffield studies on British elections from 1945 to 2005. David Butler's eternal interest in the elections is not only about quantifying. He said that he was sorry to see the "human nature, the analysis and the journalistic side" of politics and voting being drowned by sheer mathematics. Butler found Britain's last general election as the most exciting ever. About his own voting behaviour he said: "I did not vote in the 1950's, but since then I have consistently voted for all parties."
Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism 
