What Happens Inside A Top-Secret U.S. Nuclear Facility?
Feb 11, 2025
auto_awesome
Geoff Brumfiel, NPR's science correspondent, shares insights from his exclusive tour of a top-secret underground nuclear research facility. He discusses the shift from actual nuclear tests to advanced simulations powered by supercomputers. The conversation dives into the geopolitical implications of potential future nuclear testing as nations like Russia and China ramp up their capabilities. Brumfiel also highlights the historical context of U.S. nuclear policy and the environmental risks tied to this intense scrutiny of nuclear weapons.
The transition from above-ground nuclear testing to computer simulations and subcritical experiments showcases advancements in safety and technology in the nuclear field.
Political tensions with nations like Russia and China may provoke the U.S. to consider resuming nuclear tests, raising concerns about a new arms race.
Deep dives
The Evolution of Nuclear Testing
Nuclear testing by the United States has transformed dramatically since the Cold War, moving from above-ground tests to more controlled underground experiments. After stopping above-ground tests in the 1960s due to environmental concerns, the U.S. shifted focus to underground testing until a cessation in 1992, influenced by political and technological advancements. With the rise of powerful supercomputers, such as the El Capitan at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, simulations can now effectively model nuclear weapons without actual detonations. Scientists utilize advanced computing capabilities to confirm the reliability of nuclear arsenals while ensuring compliance with testing moratoriums.
Innovations in Subcritical Experiments
Underground testing facilities now conduct subcritical experiments, which simulate nuclear conditions without triggering a full chain reaction, allowing scientists to gather necessary data safely. For instance, the Scorpius machine, a powerful x-ray device, is being constructed to analyze aging plutonium from America's nuclear arsenal, highlighting the ongoing need for real-world data despite advancements in computational modeling. These innovations provide a controlled environment while eliminating the risks associated with full nuclear tests. The use of subcritical testing stands as an example of how scientists aim to ensure nuclear safety while adhering to international agreements.
Political Pressures and the Risk of Resuming Tests
The possibility of the U.S. resuming nuclear tests is driven more by political motives than scientific necessity, as international tensions rise with countries like Russia and China advancing their nuclear capabilities. Should either nation conduct a test, the U.S. would face pressure to respond, potentially igniting a new arms race. Concerns arise over the environmental and humanitarian consequences of any resumption, historically affecting marginalized communities. Maintaining a strategic advantage relies on the U.S.'s extensive history of nuclear tests; however, further testing could enable other nations to catch up rapidly.
The U.S. tested nuclear weapons until the early 1990s. Since then, scientists have been using supercomputers and experiments to simulate nuclear test detonations, without detonating any nukes. But there are signs the world's nuclear powers may be readying to test again: Russia, China and the U.S. are all upgrading their nuclear test sites.
NPR science correspondent Geoff Brumfiel was among a small group of journalists allowed to tour an underground laboratory where this research happens.
Read more of science correspondent Geoff Brumfiel's reporting here.
Help shape the future of Short Wave by taking our survey: npr.org/shortwavesurvey
Listen to every episode of Short Wave sponsor-free and support our work at NPR by signing up for Short Wave+ at plus.npr.org/shortwave.