

Crash of Civilisations
Oct 13, 2025
In a fiery discussion, the hosts tackle Samuel P. Huntington's theories, arguing their weaknesses and how history complicates the definition of Western civilization. They explore how capitalism erodes pluralism and the independence of institutions, including universities, which face corporatisation challenges. The episode also highlights the tension between capitalism's innovation and the consolidation that stifles creativity. Finally, podcasting is celebrated as a relatively non-corporate space, connecting listeners while navigating commercial pressures.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Pluralism As Western Continuity
- Charles argues Western continuity may be defined by pluralism rather than static cultural traits.
- He links overlapping local powers (guilds, monasteries) to a durable social resilience across centuries.
Capitalism Erodes Local Pluralism
- Charles says capitalism corrodes pluralism by making everything uniform and commodified.
- He warns corporatisation pushes governments and institutions to serve capital instead of preserving contesting powers.
Universities Replaced By Corporate Management
- Charles recounts how universities used to protect academic independence for a thousand years.
- He describes recent managerial takeover by consultants who apply corporate five-step processes to academia.