The Counsel of Trent #1025 - Protestants Still Can't Explain James 2
17 snips
Apr 30, 2025 The discussion dives deep into the debate over justification, examining St. James's perspective on faith and works. It contrasts Protestant and Catholic interpretations, shedding light on Martin Luther’s views. The podcast unpacks common Protestant explanations for this contentious scripture, revealing the complexities of faith versus works. Listeners will gain insights into historical perspectives and theological arguments that continue to shape Christian discourse today.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Luther's Conflict with James
- Martin Luther was conflicted about the letter of James and called it an "epistle of straw."
- Despite frustration, he never removed it from the Bible and admitted it promulgates God's laws.
Faith Alone Is Dead Faith?
- James teaches faith is good, but faith alone without works is dead and cannot save.
- Protestant claims of "dead faith" or "false faith" as different types distort James' consistent praise of faith.
Faith Requires Works to Live
- James contrasts faith alone versus faith completed by works, not true faith versus fake faith.
- Works make faith alive; faith alone without works is dead, not merely intellectually assent.