NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal Week 4 Picks Against the Spread with Nick Shook
Oct 2, 2026
Nick Shook, an NFL analyst and writer focused on team evaluation and statistics, joins Gregg Rosenthal to tackle Week 4 against-the-spread picks. They debate Miami’s big underdog line, Washington’s defense in London, Seattle exposing the Chargers, the Jets’ upside, Arizona’s matchup with the Giants, and the emotional edge in Falcons-Saints.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Rosenthal’s Four-Week Losing Start Still Became 35-19
- Gregg Rosenthal recalled starting last season with four straight losing weeks before finishing 35-19.<br>- He used that turnaround to argue that a poor September record does not define the season.
Why Shook Trusted Miami’s Huge Underdog Spread
- Nick Shook backed Miami plus 10.5 because the Dolphins improved against Kansas City while Minnesota’s offense still lacks an identity.<br>- The matchup suggested a large spread could matter more than the teams’ records.
Jacksonville’s Complete Profile Challenged Cincinnati
- Gregg Rosenthal saw Jacksonville as a complete team facing a vulnerable Cincinnati secondary.<br>- Injuries to the Bengals’ slot corner and safeties strengthened his belief that Liam Cohen could exploit the matchup.