Living Mirrors with Dr. James Cooke Richard Oerton on the harmful myth of free will | Living Mirrors #45
Mar 31, 2021
Richard Oerton, a seasoned lawyer and prolific author known for his advocacy on penal reform, dives deep into the contentious topic of free will. He argues that the concept is not only a myth but also a harmful one, often justifying societal cruelty. Oerton critiques traditional notions of personal choice and accountability, suggesting that our actions are shaped by biology and environment. He emphasizes the need for a justice system focused on rehabilitation, advocating for empathy towards those affected by circumstances beyond their control.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Early Determinism
- Richard Oerton's deterministic view formed at age 14, realizing cause-and-effect chains shape individuals.
- His classmates dismissed this idea.
Free Will Defined
- Oerton argues against the popular notion of free will, where choices aren't predetermined.
- Compatibilist free will acknowledges determinism; you're free to act on desires, but not choose them.
Nonsense of Free Will
- Rejecting determinism implies actions are random, not reflecting credit or blame.
- 'A little bit of free will' within determinism is nonsensical, as randomness adds nothing meaningful.
