Assess THAT with Tom & Nat! (Assessment, Feedback, Grading, and Learning) 27 - The Hidden Cost of Implementation Errors in Assessment & Grading
When educators say, “We tried that… and it didn’t work,” the conversation often stops there. But what if the problem isn’t the idea itself (e.g., feedback, reassessment, rubrics, or standards-based grading) but the way it was implemented? In this episode of Assess THAT, Tom & Nat explore the often-overlooked distinction between sound assessment ideas and the implementation choices that bring them to life. Through concrete classroom and leadership examples, they unpack why promising practices are so frequently abandoned before they’ve had a real chance to succeed.
Taking a coaching-oriented lens, this conversation invites educators to slow down, reflect, and ask better questions before dismissing powerful approaches to assessment and grading. You’ll hear about common implementation errors - surface adoption, misaligned beliefs, missing conditions, and unrealistic expectations - and how refining implementation can restore trust in practices that genuinely support student learning. This episode is a reminder that implementation is not a checklist, but a professional design challenge worth getting right.
🍁 CANADIAN ASSESSMENT CENTRE
Join our mailing list for assessment strategies, new podcast episodes, upcoming events, and all things Canadian Assessment. Join Here
PROFESSIONAL LEARNING EVENTS
-Mar. 18-21, 2026 (Tom) EARCOS Teacher Conference (Bangkok, TH)
-Apr. 1-2, 2026 (Tom) Grading from the Inside Out (Franklin, TN)
-Apr. 9-10, 2026 Canadian Assessment Spring Conference (Vancouver, BC)
NEW BOOK FROM TOM & NAT
CONNECT WITH TOM & NATALIE