The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Reaction to Mac Jones & 49ers UPSET WIN vs. Matt Stafford & Rams on TNF
Oct 3, 2025
Former NFL scout John Middlekauff dives into the thrilling upset of the 49ers over the Rams, sharing his immediate reactions and analyzing key plays. He dissects the 49ers' injury woes and critiques their management under Kyle Shanahan. The discussion turns to Lamar Jackson and the potential pitfalls for the Ravens this season, alongside a debate on Tyreek Hill's Hall of Fame credentials. Lastly, John highlights why this week is crucial for the Buffalo Bills and offers insights into the league's struggling teams.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Mac Jones' Grit Saved The 49ers
- John Middlekauff calls Mac Jones' start one of the grittiest backup performances he's seen and compares it to legendary games.
- He argues Mac's toughness and Kyle Shanahan's system kept the 49ers afloat despite massive injuries.
49ers' Injury Pattern Is A Systemic Problem
- Middlekauff highlights an alarming injury cascade for the 49ers and questions their medical and coaching decisions.
- He calls the team's handling of Brock Purdy and recurring injuries an embarrassing organizational problem.
Scheme Can't Hide Offensive Line Faults
- He praises Kyle Shanahan's offensive scheming but notes the team's offensive line weaknesses expose quarterbacks repeatedly.
- Middlekauff connects roster construction choices to higher injury and performance risk for the 49ers.