The Morning Edition Introducing: Diagnosing Murder
Oct 2, 2025
This engaging podcast dives into the harrowing world of shaken baby syndrome. It examines accusations against parents who claim innocence while facing devastating legal consequences. The show critiques the medical and legal systems that may be failing these families. With personal stories and high-profile cases, it challenges listeners to reconsider the science and the stigma surrounding this controversial diagnosis. As the investigation unfolds, the emotional turmoil of affected families adds a poignant layer to the discussion.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Panic At The Hospital
- A parent describes a sudden night when their baby went limp and stopped breathing, prompting panic and a rushed hospital visit.
- Medical staff immediately suggested the parent had shaken the child and ordered them to leave the hospital.
Diagnosis Versus Doubt
- Doctors interpret clinical signs as evidence of violent shaking and diagnose 'shaken baby syndrome' as the cause.
- That diagnosis has become controversial, with courts and experts questioning the reliability of the medical findings.
International Skepticism, Local Orthodoxy
- Overseas courts have overturned convictions and labelled shaken baby syndrome 'junk science' in some cases.
- Despite international skepticism, Australian medical practice remains largely unchallenged and treats abuse as the sole explanation.