What the Salman Rushdie trial means for free speech
Feb 20, 2025
auto_awesome
Will Pavia, New York correspondent for The Times, and Robbie Millen, literary editor at The Times, dive into the chilling ramifications of the trial surrounding Salman Rushdie's brutal attack. They discuss the chaos of the incident and its impact on Rushdie's literary journey, revealing the ongoing threats to freedom of expression. The conversation also touches on the trial's implications for modern publishing and the voices rising against authoritarianism in literature. This critical dialogue examines how such events reshape our understanding of free speech today.
Salman Rushdie's recent attack not only highlights the risks faced by writers but also the enduring struggle for freedom of expression.
The trial of Hadi Mattar raises critical questions about the balance between artistic freedom and the violent repercussions that can ensue.
Deep dives
The Attack on Salman Rushdie
The episode details the shocking attack on Salman Rushdie, which occurred during a speaking engagement in Chautauqua, New York. A man, later identified as Hadi Mattar, rushed the stage and stabbed Rushdie multiple times, leaving him with severe injuries, including the loss of vision in one eye. Eyewitnesses initially mistook the assault for a rehearsed act until the gravity of the situation became clear, prompting audience members to intervene. The swift response from medical professionals in the audience proved crucial in Rushdie's survival, allowing him to receive immediate trauma care.
Salman Rushdie's Legacy and Influence
Salman Rushdie is not only a renowned novelist but also a prominent symbol of free speech, particularly in the context of literary expression's fragility. His novel, 'Midnight’s Children,' which received critical acclaim, showcases his unique storytelling style that blends fantasy with historical narratives. However, it was his work 'The Satanic Verses' that ignited a global controversy, leading to a fatwa for his assassination issued by the Iranian leader Ayatollah Khomeini. Rushdie’s literary career has inspired countless writers, making him a pivotal figure in discussions surrounding freedom of expression and its limits.
Court Proceedings and Implications for Free Speech
The ongoing trial of Hadi Mattar raises important questions about the implications of Rushdie's attack for free speech and the security of writers today. Mattar has been charged with attempted murder, but his defense claims that he intended to attend the event and not harm anyone, a stance that raises eyebrows given the overwhelming evidence of his actions. Rushdie now stands as a staunch advocate for free expression, having sustained his literary career despite years of threats and isolation. The episode underscores the continuing challenges faced by writers addressing controversial topics and illustrates how fear can stifle crucial discourse in society.
The British-Indian novelist Sir Salman Rushdie has faced his alleged attacker in court, after he was stabbed multiple times in 2022 during a public lecture in New York state. Hadi Matar, accused of assault and attempted murder, denies the charges. The author is no stranger to threats: in 1989, Iran's Supreme Leader called for his death, after deeming his novel The Satanic Verses blasphemous. Will this attack on Rushdie, a symbol of free speech himself, threaten freedom of expression?
This podcast was brought to you thanks to the support of readers of The Times and The Sunday Times. Subscribe today: http://thetimes.com/thestory
Guests:
Will Pavia, New York Correspondent, The Times.
Robbie Millen, Literary Editor, The Times and The Sunday Times.