Lucy Fisher hosts a riveting discussion with Financial Times experts Robert Shrimsley, Stephen Bush, and Jim Pickard. They delve into Labour's tumultuous path ahead, spotlighting Sir Keir Starmer's struggles with low popularity and pressing issues like the NHS and immigration. The team analyzes Kemi Badenoch’s challenge in the Conservative Party, the implications of potential tax rises, and the looming local elections. They even explore how Donald Trump's potential return may reshape UK politics, adding another layer of complexity to an uncertain year.
Labour's government is under pressure to provide decisive action on NHS reforms amid criticism for its lack of urgency and clear plans.
The party must effectively address immigration concerns to maintain voter confidence while facing scrutiny over its resemblance to Conservative strategies.
Deep dives
Labour's NHS and Economic Challenges
The Labour government faces significant challenges in managing the NHS and revitalizing the economy, which were their two primary missions upon entering office. Discussions indicate that although there have been some preliminary actions, a clear and comprehensive NHS plan is yet to be revealed, with key announcements expected in the spring. Health Secretary Wes Streeting has been acknowledged for his charismatic leadership, but the delayed rollout of substantial changes raises questions about the government’s urgency and effectiveness. As the government approaches its first year, it risks losing momentum and facing criticism for inaction on critical health issues.
Social Care Commission Delays
The government has initiated a long-term commission to address the enduring issue of social care, led by Baroness Casey, but findings are not expected until 2028. This timeline reflects a broader hesitation within the government regarding immediate reform, with some advocating for more decisive action instead of lengthy commissions. Concerns have been raised that the government's immediate plans may lack actionable strategies, leaving unresolved questions about funding and the political implications of any proposed reforms. The delayed approach appears to prioritize political safety over addressing what has been a long-standing crisis in the social care system.
Immigration Policy and Labour's Position
Labour’s stance on immigration continues to present a challenge as the party grapples with increasing numbers of illegal migration across the English Channel. Despite calls for robust policy responses, there is skepticism about Labour's ability to develop effective immigration solutions that differentiate them from existing Conservative strategies. The party is positioned precariously as public concern over immigration grows, and potential missteps could further complicate its electoral prospects. Critics suggest that while Labour may benefit from previous Conservative failures in border control, without a clear policy, they risk losing voter confidence.
Future Policy Reviews and Political Landscape
Looking ahead, the upcoming Strategic Defence Review and various welfare reforms will be crucial for the Labour government as they strive to establish their policy direction. The government faces pressure to demonstrate effectiveness in critical areas, as delays and indecisiveness could diminish public support and lead to increased scrutiny. Notably, the party must navigate complex issues such as funding constraints while aiming for ambitious reforms in defence and welfare. Failure to act decisively could hinder Labour's capacity to deliver on promises, especially as local elections loom, potentially reshaping the political landscape.
After a rocky start in office for Labour, the next 12 months will prove pivotal for the UK government. Sir Keir Starmer must grapple with dismal popularity ratings, tough public finances, anaemic growth forecasts and a string of challenging policy decisions. Opposition parties also face key tests. Can Tory leader Kemi Badenoch silence critics’ warnings about her low visibility and output, and can Reform UK’s Nigel Farage prove his party’s momentum is real and not mere mirage? Host Lucy Fisher is joined by FT colleagues Robert Shrimsley, Stephen Bush and Jim Pickard to gaze into their crystal balls and consider the year ahead. They discuss the coming local elections, the spectre of Westminster by-elections, the impact of Donald Trump’s return to the Oval Office and more.
Sign up here for 30 free days of Stephen Bush's Inside Politics newsletter, winner of the World Association of News Publishers 2023 ‘Best Newsletter’ award.
Presented by Lucy Fisher. Produced by Lulu Smyth. The executive producer is Manuela Saragosa. Audio mix and original music by Breen Turner. The FT’s head of audio is Cheryl Brumley.