The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Is Caleb Williams a BUST, QB and Coach relationship, 49ers CUT Moody
Sep 10, 2025
Caleb Williams' recent struggles spark debate about his future potential and the looming bust label. The critical dynamics between quarterbacks and coaches take center stage, highlighting how this relationship can make or break careers. Meanwhile, the San Francisco 49ers face tough choices, having cut their kicker, raising questions about their future plans. Is there a deeper strategy behind the roster moves? The conversation also dives into listener questions, making for an engaging wrap-up.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Caleb's Inconsistency Threatens Progress
- Caleb Williams showed wildly inconsistent play, which makes his long-term outlook uncertain after 18 pro games.
- John Middlekauff says Ben Johnson's timing-based offense needs a quarterback who hits throws on schedule to succeed.
Prioritize Quarterback-Savvy Coaches
- Hire coaches who can develop different quarterback types instead of assuming traits will translate.
- Rely on a quarterback coach to fix flaws quickly because teams now give short leashes to top picks.
Coaching Wins Trump Pure Prospect Hype
- Coaches who can win with varied quarterbacks add organizational value beyond one draft pick.
- Middlekauff cites Kevin O'Connell and Andy Reid as examples who succeeded across different QB profiles.