48 Hours

Mind of a Serial Killer

Jul 31, 2025
Delve into the chilling tale of Donald Miller, a seemingly ordinary young man turned prime suspect in a series of disappearances. Explore the emotional toll on victims' families as they fight against potential early release. Hear about the complexities surrounding the trial, including a controversial debate on whether shoelaces can be classified as weapons. Experts weigh in on the dark psychology behind Miller's actions and the community's fear of unresolved tragedy. This gripping narrative raises profound questions about evil, justice, and the lasting impact of violence.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

Boy Next Door Disappears

  • Donald Miller appeared as the perfect, clean-cut, religious boy next door in East Lansing, Michigan.
  • His engagement to Martha Sue Young ended abruptly just before her mysterious disappearance on New Year's Eve 1976.
ANECDOTE

Attack on Gilbert Siblings

  • Donald Miller attacked 14-year-old Lisa Gilbert and 13-year-old Randy Gilbert in their home.
  • Lisa narrowly escaped and a witness noted Miller's license plate, leading police to finally arrest him.
ANECDOTE

Memory Recovery Leads To Confession

  • Psychologists used sodium amytol to help Miller recover repressed memories.
  • Miller confessed and led police to the remaining bodies of his victims.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app