Comedy Censorship Used to be WORSE with Kliph Nesteroff
Jan 24, 2024
auto_awesome
Kliph Nesteroff, a historian of comedy, explores the history of censorship in comedy and debunks the notion of audiences being "too sensitive". They discuss the evolution of comedy censorship, modern taboos, cancel culture, and the distorted narrative of free speech on college campuses. They also touch on legal consequences faced by comedians and the impact of technology on our perception of world events.
American society is more permissive about speech than in the past, debunking the claim that censorship is on the rise.
Conservative groups intentionally incite protests on college campuses to portray them as anti-free speech and further their own agenda.
Censorship exists today but is not as extreme as in the past, with contemporary taboos mainly focusing on offensive language and remarks.
Deep dives
The myth of limiting speech
There is a tiresome trend in which comics complain about being silenced and censored during their specials, but the reality is that American society is far more permissive about all types of speech than it was just a few decades ago. The idea that American culture is more censorious is actually propaganda being pushed out by the same forces that were censoring speech in the past.
The manipulation of free speech debates
The current discussion about free speech on college campuses is often propelled by billionaire-funded conservative groups and think tanks. These groups intentionally invite speakers who incite protests and then use those protests as evidence to portray colleges and universities as anti-free speech. The goal is to silence the liberal establishment and replace it with individuals supporting their own ideology.
The historical roots of censorship
Conservative think tanks like the Heritage Foundation have a long history of opposing civil rights and promoting censorship. They fund media outlets and commentators who push their agenda, framing bigoted speakers as defenders of free speech and protesters as opponents of free speech. This manipulation and funding seeks to shape public discourse and control the narrative around controversial issues.
The Evolution of Censorship: A Historical Perspective
Censorship has been a topic of debate throughout history, with different ideologies justifying their actions. Both right-wing and left-wing groups engage in censorship, claiming to protect certain values. However, the suppression of bigotry is seen as more justifiable. While censorship exists today, it is not as extreme as it was in the past, where obscenity laws and societal taboos limited free expression. Comparatively, contemporary taboos mainly revolve around offensive language and remarks, albeit not being enforced by the government.
Comedians' Battles for Freedom of Speech
Comedians in the past, like Lenny Bruce, Richard Pryor, and George Carlin, faced arrests and censorship for pushing boundaries in their acts. They challenged obscenity laws and fought for the freedom to express themselves. Today, comedians benefit from this legacy, as they have more leeway to discuss taboo subjects and use explicit language. While modern comedy still faces some taboo topics, like transgender issues, it does not equate to a complete limitation on freedom of speech seen in previous eras.
For as long as there's been comedy, there have been people lamenting that "you can't do comedy anymore". This sentiment feels more prevalent than ever, but is it actual censorship or a shift in our culture? Adam talks with Kliph Nesteroff, a historian of comedy and author of Outrageous: A History of Showbiz and the Culture Wars, about the history of censorship in comedy, and how the idea of audiences being "too sensitive" is propaganda pushed by the very same people who censored comedians in years past. Find Kliph's book at factuallypod.com/books
About Headgum: Headgum is an LA & NY-based podcast network creating premium podcasts with the funniest, most engaging voices in comedy to achieve one goal: Making our audience and ourselves laugh. Listen to our shows at https://www.headgum.com.