Islamic scholar Mufti Menk navigates the complexity of hate and compassion in Islam, discussing the delicate balance between hating sins and showing understanding towards sinners. He explores justified disapproval in certain scenarios and the potential for reconciliation and love even in moments of extreme conflict.
In Islam, it is important to hate sinful actions but not the individuals committing them, focusing on correction and guidance rather than hatred towards the person.
Detesting sinful behaviors is acceptable in Islam, with a distinction between hating the sin and the sinner, allowing for disapproval of harmful actions while still holding hope for guidance and forgiveness.
Deep dives
Importance of Hating the Sin, Not the Sinner
In Islam, it is emphasized to hate sins, blasphemy, and actions against Allah and His messenger while maintaining respect for the individual. The focus is on hating the sin itself, not the person committing it. The initial approach is to correct and guide the sinner without hatred. However, if someone actively promotes sin and harms others, then it becomes acceptable to detest their actions.
Distinguishing Between Hating the Deed and the Person
There is a distinction between hating the sin and hating the sinner in Islam. It is permissible to detest sinful actions and behaviors that go against one's values. In cases of severe wrongdoing, such as causing harm or oppression, it is justifiable to express dislike towards the individual while still maintaining hope for their guidance and forgiveness. Ultimately, Allah has the power to instill love and forgiveness even in situations of deep animosity.
1.
Navigating the Complexity of Hate and Compassion in Islam