Politicology U.S. Security: Mixed Signals, Clear Danger—The Weekly
Dec 20, 2025
Hagar Chemali, a former U.N. spokesperson and national security expert, shares insights on the 2025 National Security Strategy, highlighting its mixed messages and the internal divide between isolationists and internationalists. The discussion spans the importance of U.S. credibility in diplomacy, a pivot toward Latin America, and the ongoing challenges with China and Taiwan. Chemali emphasizes the dangers of neglecting human rights issues, particularly in Hong Kong, and addresses the alarming rise of antisemitic violence, linking it to unchecked incitement.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Strategy Reveals White House Schism
- The 2025 National Security Strategy reads inconsistent, reflecting a White House split between isolationists and internationalists.
- Hagar Chemali warns this internal chasm creates risky mixed signals for allies and adversaries.
Values Deprioritized In Partnerships
- The NSS explicitly deprioritizes values alignment, promising partnership without insisting on shared values.
- Ron Steslow finds this omission alarming because it erodes a consistent U.S. voice and moral anchor.
Economics Drive China Posture
- The NSS emphasizes economic benefit as the guiding principle for China policy rather than systemic competition.
- Hagar says administration actions, however, show a tougher, transactional stance toward Beijing.