

'YOU Are Making Jews Less Safe!' Americans Jews Debate Israel-Gaza | With Peter Beinart
4 snips Aug 8, 2025
Peter Beinart, a political science professor and author, joins pro-Israel commentator Shabbos Kestenbaum and filmmaker Katie Halper to discuss the Israeli-Palestinian conflict's impact on American Jews. They explore the nuances of Jewish identity and how the crisis has sparked internal debates about support for Israel. Topics include the rise of antisemitism, generational differences in views on the conflict, and the moral complexities behind humanitarian aid in Gaza. The dialogue emphasizes the need for respectful discourse and the weight of historical legacy in shaping present narratives.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Linked Safety For Jews And Palestinians
- Peter Beinart argues Israeli Jews' safety is intertwined with Palestinian safety.
- He warns starvation and slaughter of Palestinians will endanger future coexistence.
Historical Roots Of Gaza's Population
- Peter Beinart notes many Gazans are descendants of those expelled in 1948.
- He says that history should horrify Jews and shape policy.
Let Journalists Verify Gaza Claims
- Peter Beinart urges Israel to allow international media into Gaza to verify its claims.
- He says barring reporters signals lack of confidence in official narratives.