The Close Read Podcast

"Goodbye to the Good War" by Sean McMeekin

Oct 28, 2025
Explore the enduring myth of World War II and why it captivates us. Delve into the complexities of postwar power dynamics and the origins of the UN. Examine America’s delay in confronting fascism and the tricky motivations behind its entry into the war. Question the narrative around the Allies' role in the Holocaust and how WWII myths have fueled subsequent conflicts. Plus, consider NATO's relevance today and whether it truly serves as a defensive alliance or a provocation to Russia.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Postwar Order Was Political Construction

  • Post-1945 institutions and wartime narratives were crafted to legitimize a U.S.-Soviet dominated order rather than reflect a moral crusade.
  • Sean McMeekin argues Hollywood myths about a pure moral fight obscure messy geopolitical self-interest.
INSIGHT

U.S. War Entry Was Gradual And Strategic

  • U.S. entry into WWII reflected long-term policy shifts, not sudden moral outrage at fascism.
  • McMeekin highlights lend-lease and Roosevelt's pre-Pearl Harbor moves that made the U.S. belligerent in all but name.
ANECDOTE

Donovan's Mission And The Yugoslav Coup

  • Roosevelt sent Colonel 'Wild Bill' Donovan to warn Yugoslavia against deals with Germany, prompting a coup and German invasion.
  • The leak of Rainbow Five and other moves show U.S. actions influenced Axis decisions before Pearl Harbor.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app