The podcast dives into the pressures surrounding procreation in conservative Protestant communities. It questions the cultural and theological mandates pushing couples to have children. The discussion highlights how family structures have shifted over time, especially regarding the stigma against remaining child-free. It also tackles the crisis of church growth, revealing the tension between spiritual and biological expansion as membership declines. The evolving ideologies around family and gender roles are explored, offering insight into these complex dynamics.
The increasing emphasis on procreation among conservative Protestants is driven by demographic anxieties and a perceived need for biological church growth.
The shift in views on contraception within high-control Christian circles reflects a broader societal pressure to maintain control over reproduction and preserve cultural identity.
Deep dives
The Obligation of Parenthood in High-Control Christianity
High-control Christian subcultures in America overwhelmingly assume that marriage will result in children, with the ideology of procreation woven into their understanding of sex and marriage. The nuclear family structure, characterized by a mother, father, and their children, is seen as God's ordained model and the cornerstone of community life. Discussions surrounding family planning often frame individuals who do not plan to have children as selfish or worldly, reinforcing societal expectations surrounding childbirth. This unspoken obligation reveals a broader control mechanism, as the ideology polices personal choices under the guise of divine mandate, pushing against alternate lifestyles, such as those of queer individuals or couples who choose not to have children.
Crisis of Numbers Among Conservative Christians
The declining membership within conservative Protestant churches has heightened the emphasis on the necessity of Christian couples having children, marking a significant shift in focus for these communities. This demographic crisis is a response to a perceived threat as fewer new Christians emerge to replace those leaving the faith, leading to an urgent call for biological church growth through childbirth. The transition from merely presuming the occurrence of childbirth to formally emphasizing the need for it illustrates a cultural anxiety within high-control religious circles. The shift indicates that religious identity is increasingly tied to procreation, driven by fears of losing church influence and relevance.
Merging White Supremacy with Christian Ideology
The recent surge in calls for conservative Christians to have children correlates with broader demographic changes within the U.S., where the population is trending towards a majority-minority demographic. This shift has fueled white replacement theory, intermingling it with Christian nationalism, where the narrative posits that white Christian Americans have a divinely mandated responsibility to propagate their race. This rhetoric has recently shifted from fringe beliefs to mainstream views among Christian nationalists, making the obligation to have children an active cultural wartime issue. The convergence of these ideologies exemplifies increased anxiety among conservative whites, tying the preservation of their cultural and religious identity to the act of having more children.
Changing Perspectives on Birth Control
Historically, conservative Protestant circles accepted contraception within the framework of raising children, but this acceptance is beginning to fade amid growing opposition to birth control. While previously, leaders permitted family planning as responsible stewardship of resources, a newer generation is increasingly vocal against any form of contraception, viewing it as inconsiderate in divine planning. This change is paralleled with the rising injunction on Christians to have children, suggesting a cultural anxiety around birth rates and church growth. The shift is indicative of broader societal pressures, where high-control religious ideologies conflate control of reproduction with maintaining social power and influence.
Subscribe for $5.99 a month to get bonus content most Mondays, bonus episodes every month, ad-free listening, access to the entire 750-episode archive, Discord access, and more: https://axismundi.supercast.com/
Subscribe to One Nation, Indivisible with Andrew Seidel:
Why do conservative, high-control Protestants in America emphasize the need for Americans, especially Christians, to have children? How is this consistent with their past positions, and how has it changed over time? How does this relate to conservative Protestant views on the use of contraception, which have always been a mixed bag? And how have changing articulations of these views brough conservative Protestants and conservative Catholics closer together in their respective ideologies of sexual and gender? Listen to this week’s episode as Dan tackles these questions.