#11820 Questions from Non-Catholics - Fr. Sebastian Walshe
Aug 24, 2024
auto_awesome
Fr. Sebastian Walshe, a dedicated priest and insightful speaker on Catholic beliefs, dives into a range of compelling questions from non-Catholics. He clarifies the Church Fathers’ views on Mary’s assumption and discusses the complexities surrounding 'canton marriages.' Fr. Walshe addresses concerns about the priest sex scandal and outlines the difference between honoring saints and worshiping them. He explains the theology behind indulgences and debates the question of salvation outside the visible Church, all while sharing a poignant personal story about his mother.
Father Sebastian Walsh emphasizes that early Church teachings on Mary's assumption demonstrate historic reverence despite limited theological documentation.
The discussion of indulgences reveals their role in Catholic sacramental theology, highlighting the communal aspect of merit sharing within the Church.
Deep dives
Engaging Non-Catholics
The episode focuses on an open hour for non-Catholics to ask questions about the Catholic faith, inviting inquiries on topics that often generate disagreement with Protestant beliefs, such as purgatory, the veneration of Mary, and Church traditions. This initiative aims to facilitate understanding and promote dialogue between Catholics and non-Catholics. Viewers are encouraged to call in and participate, creating an inclusive atmosphere for discussion. The program fosters a space where curiosity and differing perspectives can be explored respectfully and thoughtfully.
Father Sebastian Walsh's Journey
Father Sebastian Walsh shares his unique conversion story that reflects a diverse background, beginning with a Jewish upbringing before transitioning to Lutheranism and finally embracing Catholicism. This journey is highlighted to encourage non-Catholic participants to engage with their questions, illustrating that faith exploration is a personal journey that resonates with those from various backgrounds. His experience underscores the transformative power of faith and serves as a source of inspiration for individuals seeking to deepen their understanding of Catholic teachings. The narrative emphasizes that spirituality can evolve through different stages and influences.
Discussion of Mary’s Bodily Assumption
A caller expresses curiosity about the historical basis for the belief in Mary’s bodily assumption into heaven, seeking clarification on its legitimacy within early Church teachings. Father Walsh explains that while early theological reflection on the topic may not be extensively documented, the belief was widely accepted among the faithful, stemming from a deep-seated reverence for Mary. He references Pope Pius XII's encyclical that formally established the dogma, highlighting early Church Fathers’ acknowledgment of the belief despite the lack of rigorous theological discourse. This illustrates the organic development of doctrine within the Church over time.
The Nature of Indulgences
One listener inquires about the concept of indulgences in the Catholic Church, specifically regarding their significance and the historical context of days associated with them. Father Walsh clarifies that indulgences represent the remission of temporal punishment for sins that have been forgiven, emphasizing the communal aspect of the Church that allows for the sharing of merits among its members. He explains the historical development of indulgences and the Church's teachings that assert the necessity of a visible community for one's spiritual journey. This highlights the importance of understanding indulgences as rooted in the Church's sacramental theology.
Questions Covered:
05:30 – I’m protestant. What did the Church Fathers believe about Mary’s assumption?
11:31 – Why is the Church not receptive to canton marriages?
15:53 – How would you respond with my reason for not returning to the Church? I won’t return because of how the priest sex scandal was handled.
21:18 – Why do we have to go right up to the borderline of worshiping the saints?
33:08 – What’s the logic on assigning day to indulgences?
38:35 – Is there salvation outside the visible Church?
47:57 – Is the Protestant bible missing any book from the canon?
52:54 – I heard your story on the Journey Home. Could you repeat the story of your mother.
…
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode