Lindsay Gibbs, founder of the Power Plays newsletter, and Charles McDonald, Yahoo Sports contributor, dive into the pressures on NFL quarterbacks, examining the risks of investing in young talent. They discuss the challenges faced by the Carolina Panthers with Bryce Young and the complexities of negotiating quarterback contracts. The conversation also touches on the stagnation of American male tennis, the rivalry between Angel Reese and Caitlin Clark in the WNBA, and the cultural influences affecting women's sports.
The NFL's escalating quarterback salaries and draft strategies highlight the urgent need for teams to evaluate talent more discernibly.
Ownership involvement, particularly exemplified by David Tepper's influence with the Panthers, underscores how management decisions can make or break franchises.
The rising visibility of female athletes like Angel Reese signifies a major cultural shift towards the appreciation and support of women's sports.
Deep dives
Quarterback Scarcity and NFL Trends
The current NFL landscape emphasizes the critical importance of having a top-tier quarterback, leading teams to make desperate decisions to secure one. This trend has intensified over the past decade, particularly since the implementation of the 2011 CBA, which introduced a rookie wage scale and a fifth-year option, reshaping how teams approach quarterback contracts. Consequently, franchises are increasingly selecting quarterbacks early in the draft, often under pressure to find a suitable candidate who can deliver results without breaking the bank. However, this strategy can backfire, leaving teams with expensive contracts for mediocre players, as evidenced by the recent struggles of quarterbacks like Kirk Cousins and Bryce Young.
Franchise Management and Ownership Issues
Ownership dynamics play a crucial role in the success or failure of NFL teams, as seen with the Carolina Panthers and their owner David Tepper. Tepper's involvement in front office decisions has generated criticism, particularly regarding how he has handled the team's quarterback situation since Cam Newton's departure. The pressure to deliver results can lead teams to make hasty decisions, such as trading multiple first-round picks for a singular player, which could ultimately sweat their future choices. It highlights how franchises can slip into a cycle of mediocrity, but a strong performance from a player like Bryce Young could significantly alter perceptions and salvage a poorly run organization.
Rookie Quarterback Expectations
Rookies entering the league, particularly quarterbacks, face immense expectations that often skew their long-term prospects. Many teams anticipate immediate success from high draft picks, leading to potential overvaluation of their abilities, which can result in future regret if they underperform. Instances of teams overrating quarterbacks based simply on draft position rather than actual capability have become common, creating an environment where franchise potential can be jeopardized by poor evaluations. Ultimately, while early signs of potential are promising, patience is required to accurately assess a quarterback's true value and development trajectory.
Quarterback Contracts and Market Dynamics
With the market for quarterbacks reaching exorbitant levels, teams often find themselves paying players who may not deliver top-tier performances. The high financial commitment linked to mediocre quarterbacks complicates franchise management, as organizations navigate the tightrope of maintaining a successful roster while investing heavily in their signal-callers. Teams like the Falcons and Giants exemplify the challenge; they committed huge sums to quarterbacks like Kirk Cousins and Daniel Jones, reflecting the broader issue of discernment in valuing quarterback talent. As a result, the strain placed on overall team resources can lead to difficult decisions down the line regarding roster sustainability and performance expectations.
Hope for Female Athletes and the WNBA
The conversations surrounding female athletes and the WNBA signal a significant shift in visibility and appreciation for women's sports. Players like Angel Reese and Caitlin Clark have become household names, invigorating interest in the league through exceptional performances and engaging narratives. Despite the toxic rivalry narratives, there's a growing recognition that both athletes are contributing to a resurgence in women's basketball, fostering a more inclusive environment for future generations. This empowerment resonates throughout the sport, encouraging young female athletes to pursue their dreams despite the obstacles, and signaling a progressive trend in the landscape of professional sports.
Slate contributing writer and co-host of the podcast Split Zone Duo, Alex Kirshner is back in the host chair this week. Joining Alex is the founder of the Power Plays newsletter, Lindsay Gibbs, and Yahoo Sports’ Charles McDonald. The panel comb through NFL Week 1, the American near victories at the US Open, and Angel Reese’s season-ending injury. In the Bonus episode, Slate Plus members can hear a discussion about Deion Sanders' disappointing Buffaloes.
NFL (3:13): The big budgets and big gambles on the current crop of QBs
US Open (23:02): The American Grand Slam drought continues.
WNBA (40:21): Angel Reese’s rookie season is cut short.
(Note: time codes are only accurate for Slate Plus members, who listen ad free.)
Want more Hang Up and Listen? Subscribe to Slate Plus to immediately unlock weekly bonus episodes. Plus, you’ll access ad-free listening across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe now on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page, or visit slate.com/hangupplus to get access wherever you listen.
