The Rational Egoist: A Debate on Immigration Policy with Michael Leibowitz and Professor Richard Aronin

The Rational Egoist: A Debate on Immigration Policy with Michael Leibowitz and Professor Richard Aronin In this episode of "The Rational Egoist," host Michael Leibowitz engages in a spirited debate with Professor Richard Aronin, Director of Procurement at NYCCT and Emeritus Professor at New York University, on the topic of immigration policy. Please note that the views expressed by Professor Richard Aronin are his personal opinions and not representative of any organization he has been associated with. The discussion delves into the ideas of renowned philosopher Ayn Rand regarding immigration. A central point of contention emerges: Does anyone have the right to pursue their self-interest through legal means or force? Professor Richard argues that immigration should be regulated through proper vetting processes, advocating for the need to establish laws to control border access without completely closing them off. He believes that Rand's views primarily pertain to fully closed borders and not reasonable restrictions. However, Michael challenges this perspective by highlighting Rand's stance against immigration restrictions rather than their complete elimination. Michael questions the constitutional authority of the federal government to restrict immigration, except during times of war with specific countries. As the conversation unfolds, Professor Richard employs the analogy of not allowing just anyone to enter your house and extends it to the country at large. Michael counters this argument by emphasising that private property rights differ from government ownership. The duo explores the concept of who owns the USA, ultimately concluding that while the government has ownership, it is bound by the Constitution and lacks inherent rights to impose restrictions on borders or immigration. The discussion touches upon concerns about individuals entering the country to cause harm, but it is noted that most immigrants contribute positively to society and add value to the nation. The infamous events of 9/11 are mentioned, with the realisation that the attackers entered on visas rather than as immigrants, indicating that vetted immigration would not have prevented such an incident. Furthermore, the conversation highlights that most crimes are committed by natural-born US citizens rather than immigrants. The argument is made that open borders and unrestricted immigration align with the principles of individual rights, as newcomers are bound by the country's laws and private property rights of others. Professor Richard's concerns about law enforcement and citizen protection are addressed, clarifying that individual rights do not advocate for the elimination of law enforcement but rather uphold the government's duty to protect its citizens. Join Michael Leibowitz and Professor Richard Aronin as they explore the nuanced perspectives on immigration policy, dissecting the intersection of individual rights, national security, and the role of government in this thought-provoking episode of "The Rational Egoist." Michael Leibowitz is a renowned philosopher, political activist, and the esteemed host of the Rational Egoist podcast. With a profound admiration for the philosopher Ayn Rand, Leibowitz passionately champions the principles of reason, rational self-interest, and individualism. As a dedicated advocate, Leibowitz's influence extends beyond his podcasting endeavours. Engaging in lively political debates, he fearlessly advocates for the protection of individual rights and freedoms through compelling YouTube videos and insightful interviews. Leibowitz's own life narrative exemplifies the transformative power of Ayn Rand's writings. Despite enduring a challenging past that led to a 25-year prison sentence, he emerged from adversity by embracing the tenets of rational self-interest and moral philosophy put forth by Ayn Rand.