The podcast delves into betrayal within the Church, comparing it to Judas betraying Christ. It discusses trusted members conspiring against Joseph Smith, including an apostle. Topics include internal factors leading to Joseph's assassination, scandalous lives of John Bennett and William Law, and confrontations within the Mormon community. Also explores the impact of the Nauvoo Expositor publication.
Internal dissent within the church fueled treacherous acts against Joseph Smith by trusted members like William Law over disputes involving plural marriage.
Chauncey and Francis Higbee's involvement in unchaste behavior and conflict with Joseph Smith added to the turmoil within the community.
Hostile sentiments towards Joseph Smith led to a complex conspiracy involving individuals like the Foster and Law brothers, culminating in tragic consequences for Joseph and Hiram Smith.
Deep dives
The Internal Dissent and Conspiracies
Internal dissent within the church led to treacherous acts against Joseph Smith, as trusted members like William Law turned against him due to disputes over plural marriage. Law's opposition and plans for the prophet's demise catalyzed the publication of the Nauvoo Expositor, aiming to incite Joseph's removal and culminated in his excommunication.
Chauncey and Francis Higbee's Controversies
Chauncey and Francis Higbee, sons of Elias Higby, faced allegations of unchaste behavior and involvement with John C. Bennett. Chauncey's seduction of women and promotion of secret promiscuity led to his excommunication. Francis Higbee's lowered reputation due to contracting a venereal disease from a prostitute visited Nauvoo adds to the turmoil within the community.
Revealed Hostility and Murderous Intent
Hostile sentiments towards Joseph Smith manifested in William Law's excommunication and subsequent murderous intentions. Exposed by contemporary testimonies, Law's acquisition of pistols and attempts to assassinate Joseph illustrate the potent animosity present among certain members of the trusted church community.
Francis Higby's Conflicts with Joseph Smith
Francis Higby was involved in multiple conflicts with Joseph Smith, including a court case where he accused William Marks and William Law of potential disagreements with church teachings. Despite a reconciliation where Joseph forgave Higby for slandering him, their relationship remained tense. Higby later aligned with anti-Smith individuals, leading to further animosity and eventually culminating in his excommunication from the church.
Conspiracy Against Joseph Smith
A complex conspiracy against Joseph Smith involved individuals like the Foster and Law brothers, Chauncey Higby, and others. The plot escalated with threats, altercations, and accusations aimed at Joseph Smith, ultimately resulting in excommunications and a plan to publish the Nauvoo Expositor. This detailed scheme eventually led to Joseph and Hiram Smith's tragic deaths, highlighting the severe consequences of the ongoing conflicts and conspiracies surrounding Joseph Smith.
Six months before his death the prophet Joseph said to a group of trusted friends, “I am exposed to far greater danger from traitors among ourselves than from enemies without, … and if I can escape from the ungrateful treachery of assassins I can live as Caesar might have lived were it not for a right hand Brutus…. All the enemies upon the face of the earth may roar and exert all their power to bring about my death; but they can accomplish nothing, unless some who are among us, enjoying our society, [who] have been with us in our Councils, participated in our confidence, taken us by the hand, called us brother, [and] saluted us with a kiss, join with our enemies, turn our virtues into faults, and by falsehood and deceit, stir up their wrath and indignation against us, and bring their united vengeance upon our heads.” And then he said, “Judas was one of the Twelve Apostles … and through his treachery, the crucifixion [of Christ] was brought about, and we have a Judas in our midst.” (source)
In this episode of Church History Matters, we discuss what we know about those trusted Church members who treacherously turned on Joseph Smith and conspired to bring about his death—one of whom, like Judas of old, was an apostle and counselor to the prophet.