Michael Schulman, a staff writer at The New Yorker and author of 'Oscar Wars', dives into the chaotic world of Oscar contenders, focusing on the controversial film 'Emilia Perez'. He discusses its unique blend of a trans storyline and cartel narrative, sparking debate over creative risks versus negative stereotypes. The film’s surprising Oscar nominations raise questions about Hollywood's evolving identity politics. Schulman also highlights social media backlash against representation and the challenges facing films during this tumultuous award season.
The film 'Amelia Perez' presents a complex blend of absurdity and serious themes, yet faces criticism for its confusing narrative and cultural representation.
Controversies surrounding the actress's past comments and Netflix's distancing highlight the precarious balance of representation and backlash in Hollywood awards season.
Deep dives
The Baffling Narrative of Amelia Perez
Amelia Perez is a unique film that blends an absurdist musical approach with serious themes, focusing on a trans cartel boss seeking redemption after a gender transition. The storyline includes her reconnection with family and the establishment of a nonprofit to help victims of gang violence, creating a complex narrative that mixes elements of comedy, tragedy, and drama. Critics point out that the film's tonal shifts and absurd scenarios leave audiences questioning its artistic merit, especially scenes like the awkward portrayal of gender reassignment surgeries in musical numbers. This complex interplay of themes and styles may leave viewers confused, raising the question of what the intended message truly is.
Criticism of Representation and Stereotypes
The film has faced considerable scrutiny for its portrayal of Mexican culture and the lack of authentic representation within its production, as few Mexican voices were involved despite the setting and subject matter. Critics argue that the film reinforces outdated stereotypes about drug cartels and violence while failing to adequately explore genuine narratives about the experiences of trans individuals. Moreover, the choice of a French director and predominantly non-Mexican cast has raised concerns about the authenticity of its storytelling. The film illustrates the ongoing challenges of addressing representation in media, often resulting in tokenism rather than genuine inclusion.
Oscars Controversy and Its Aftermath
Amelia Perez's nomination and associated campaign for the Oscars uncovered a series of controversies that intensified scrutiny and debate over its legitimacy. Notably, the lead actress faced backlash after inflammatory comments resurfaced, raising questions about her suitability as a representative for the trans community during awards season. As the Oscars approached, Netflix distanced itself from the actress amid the growing criticism, jeopardizing the film's chances for recognition and clouding its achievements. This situation reflects the precarious nature of representation in Hollywood, where the desire for diversity can intertwine with the potential for backlash when the realities of representation do not align with societal values and context.
As Donald Trump’s campaign of trans panic and anti-Latin American sentiment buoyed him back to the White House, Emilia Pérez looked like a film to meet the moment. Then audiences started actually seeing it and...yikes.
Want more What Next? Join Slate Plus to unlock full, ad-free access to What Next and all your other favorite Slate podcasts. You can subscribe directly from the What Next show page on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme and Rob Gunther.