NFL Stock Exchange: An NFL Draft Podcast NFL Week 1 Rookie Report: Reviewing the BEST and WORST Rookie Performances
Sep 14, 2026
A first-week audit of the NFL’s rookie class, featuring early Offensive and Defensive Rookie of the Year rankings. Standout debuts, surprise contributors, and disappointing introductions take center stage, from Jacob Rodriguez’s huge tackle total to Caleb Downs’ game-changing play. The discussion also covers emerging roles, scheme fits, tough matchups, and listener questions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
One Week Can Distort Rookie Rankings
- Connor Rogers ranked rookies from a one-week sample rather than relying on preseason expectations.
- He warned that early rankings will shift as volume, injuries, and roles clarify over the first month.
Antonio Williams Earned More Routes
- Antonio Williams turned only 10 routes into four catches, 64 yards, and a touchdown against Philadelphia.
- His efficient debut should force Washington to expand his role behind Terry McLaurin and Stefon Diggs.
Love Made Inefficient Runs Work
- Jeremiyah Love produced 41 yards and a touchdown on 11 carries despite returning from a high ankle sprain.
- He occasionally bounced outside too eagerly, but his athleticism repeatedly erased inefficient decisions.