What Christianity Gets Wrong About Mental Illness—and What a Biblical Theology Can Redeem

How should followers of Jesus approach mental health in a way that’s faithful, honest, and deeply human? In this vulnerable and theology-rich conversation, Mike Erre, Bonnie Lewis, and Tim Stafford unpack the complexities of mental illness through a biblical lens. Building a positive theology of mental health, they respond to a viral Christian post that stigmatized mental illness among pastors—particularly surrounding suicide and leadership in the church.

Together, the hosts challenge damaging narratives and explore how the church can become a redemptive, healing community for those navigating anxiety, depression, trauma, and spiritual struggle.

Key Takeaways: • Theological Missteps on Mental Health – Addressing the harmful assumption that mental illness is incompatible with Christian leadership and exploring the flawed linkage between mental illness, apostasy, and doctrinal doubt. • A Biblical Theology of Mental Health – How scripture offers robust categories for mental illness through the lenses of the imago Dei, embodiment, communal identity, and the effects of the Fall. • Jesus and Mental Illness – What the Gospels reveal about God’s presence with the suffering and the misunderstood, and how Jesus modeled compassion and holistic healing. • Church Culture and Vulnerability – Why the church's overemphasis on strength, certainty, and positivity needs to be replaced by embracing lament, doubt, and emotional honesty. • Leadership and Struggle – Why brokenness doesn't disqualify leaders, but unacknowledged weakness might. The necessity of structure, accountability, and a broader definition of health in ministry. • Restoring Belonging – Critiquing the theology of “unbelonging” that drives suffering people into isolation rather than into community, and reclaiming the church’s mandate to embody reconciliation, restoration, and grace.

Resource Highlights: • Book: The Body Keeps the Score by Bessel van der Kolk – A key resource for understanding how trauma is experienced and stored in the body. • Book: Finding Quiet by J.P. Moreland – A theologically rooted personal story of overcoming anxiety and finding peace through integrated care. • Book: People of the Lie by M. Scott Peck – Explores evil's psychological and spiritual manifestations. • Biblical Texts Referenced – Psalms (especially 6, 13, 88), Job, Lamentations, the Gospels (Jesus and healing marginalized individuals), and Elijah’s story in 1 Kings 19. • Therapeutic Approaches – Discussion of therapy modalities, including EMDR (referenced but unnamed), the effectiveness of talk therapy, and the mindful use of medication with spiritual discernment.

Engage with this vital conversation and join us in reshaping how the church thinks, talks about, and responds to mental health realities—with compassion, truth, and a commitment to wholeness.

We’d love to hear your story or thoughts as we continue pursuing this essential dialogue. Email us anytime at hello@voxpodcast.com, and join the conversation on Facebook and Instagram.

We're also on YouTube: VOXOLOGY TV

Check out the VOXOLOGY Merch Store on ETSY

Support the Voxology Podcast on Patreon

Learn more about the show at voxologypodcast.com

Subscribe on iTunes or Spotify

Follow @voxologypodcast on Instagram and like us on Facebook

Follow Mike on Twitter: @mikeerre

Music in this episode by Timothy John Stafford Instagram & Twitter: @GoneTimothy



As always, we encourage and would love discussion as we pursue. Feel free to email in questions to hello@voxpodcast.com, and to engage the conversation on Facebook and Instagram.

We're on YouTube (if you're into that kinda thing): VOXOLOGY TV.

Our Merch Store! ETSY

Learn more about the Voxology Podcast

Subscribe on iTunes or Spotify

Support the Voxology Podcast on Patreon

The Voxology Spotify channel can be found here: Voxology Radio

Follow us on Instagram: @voxologypodcast and "like" us on Facebook

Follow Mike on Twitter: www.twitter.com/mikeerre

Music in this episode by Timothy John Stafford

Instagram & Twitter: @GoneTimothy