The Musical Dilemma

The film 'Joker: Folie à Deux' presents itself as a courtroom drama and a romance with musical elements, yet it struggles to define its identity clearly. The filmmakers claim it is not a musical, which contrasts with the frequent and emotive singing occurring throughout the film. This ambiguity leads to confusion about the purpose and execution of the musical numbers, which often feel disconnected from the narrative. Critics question whether the musical format serves to deepen the story or merely distract from it, highlighting a significant flaw in the film's structure.