Trump’s Ex-Border Chief Ken Cuccinelli on Deporting 20 Million People
Jan 14, 2025
auto_awesome
Ken Cuccinelli, the ex-deputy secretary of Homeland Security under Trump, dives into the complex realities of mass deportation plans. He discusses the immense logistical challenges of removing 10 to 20 million undocumented immigrants and the staggering potential costs, estimating $88 billion annually. Cuccinelli also tackles the legal implications of using military forces for deportations and the potential partnerships with third countries to manage migration flows, revealing the political and economic intricacies behind these ambitious proposals.
Mass deportation poses significant logistical and financial challenges, potentially costing $88 billion and requiring extensive transportation resources over a prolonged period.
A Trump administration could shift immigration enforcement tactics by involving the military, altering border security dynamics and impacting illegal crossings significantly.
Deep dives
The Feasibility of Mass Deportation
Mass deportation of millions of undocumented individuals poses significant logistical challenges. Deporting one million people would require transporting them in large groups, potentially utilizing 50 jumbo jets daily for an entire year, which is a daunting task. Current estimates suggest that deporting just one million individuals could cost upwards of $88 billion over ten years, highlighting the financial burden of such an undertaking. The complexity also includes identifying individuals, obtaining arrests, interfacing with chaotic legal proceedings, and much more, making the promise of mass deportation seem more hypothetical than practical.
Presidential Authority and Enforcement Changes
The governance structure allows a president to initiate significant changes to immigration enforcement immediately upon taking office. A Trump administration would shift the role of Border Patrol from merely processing entry to actively enforcing border controls, potentially employing military support. This adjustment suggests an increased physical presence at the border, which could deter illegal crossings and immediately influence border security. The introduction of tactical military involvement would significantly alter the on-ground approach to handling immigration.
Political Dynamics Affecting Disaster Relief
Disaster response has become entangled with political relations, particularly between state and federal levels, as demonstrated in California's response to wildfires. The relationship between President Trump and Governor Newsom has fluctuated, impacting the flow of disaster relief resources. Ken Cuccinelli points out that excessive reliance on FEMA can hinder states from preparing adequately for emergencies, which raises concerns about funding and resource allocation in major disaster events. Cooperation between state and federal authorities is essential for effective disaster management, yet political disagreements often lead to complications.
Economic Implications of Immigration Policy
Immigration policy directly affects the labor market and economic conditions for American workers, particularly the lower-income demographic. Research indicates that in times of strict immigration enforcement, wages for these workers can improve, creating more job opportunities. However, this potential benefit must be weighed against the likelihood of increased prices for goods and services, as businesses adapt to new labor dynamics. Striking a balance between enforcement and economic reality remains a central challenge in reshaping immigration policy.
Tara is joined by ex-deputy secretary of Homeland Security Ken Cuccinelli to talk about the viability of Donald Trump’s ambitious immigration reforms on the eve of his inauguration. They discuss the legality of using the military to execute mass deportations, debate the effects they will have on the American people, and break down the national and international logistics of implementing such a large scale plan.
For more of Tara’s reporting, please sign up for her newsletter, 'The Best and the Brightest,' at puck.news/tarapalmeri and use the discount code TARA20.