Self in Society Podcast Michael Huemer on Rationality and Objectivity
Apr 18, 2021
Philosopher Michael Huemer discusses rationality, objectivity, and the complexity of fact versus opinion. He explores justice system flaws, personal identity, rational thinking variation, and the impact of media on public perception. The conversation also delves into truth, belief, skepticism, and the role of intuition in ethical reasoning.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Justice Before The Law Overview
- Michael Huemer describes Justice Before the Law focusing on prioritizing justice over strict law following.
- He cites plea-bargain coercion and disproportionate sentences as examples motivating reform.
What Epistemic Rationality Really Means
- Epistemic rationality means forming beliefs supported by evidence and avoiding contradictions.
- What is rational can vary between people depending on their evidence and testimony.
Belief Formation Can Be Morally Wrong
- Clifford argues it's morally wrong to hold beliefs on insufficient evidence using the ship-owner example.
- The moral blameworthiness doesn't vanish if luck prevents harm, so forming unjustified beliefs is wrong regardless of outcomes.