Forum Borealis

David Lawrence - The Case for Free Will (Against the Absurdity of Determinism) - PRE-RELEASE

10 snips
Apr 5, 2025
David Lawrence, author of 'Are We Really Biochemical Robots?', dives into the contentious debate between free will and determinism. He critiques thinkers like Sam Harris, arguing that deterministic views undermine personal autonomy. The conversation explores the implications of quantum mechanics on free will, challenges misconceptions in neuroscience, and examines how societal structures can limit individual choices. Lawrence also highlights the importance of personal responsibility and the ethical dilemmas posed by a deterministic worldview.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Defining Determinism

  • Determinism posits that all thoughts and actions are predetermined by physical causes since the Big Bang.
  • This view portrays humans as biochemical robots without genuine choice or control.
INSIGHT

Influence vs. Causation

  • Determinism mistakenly equates influence with causation.
  • Free will operates within limitations and influences but is not determined by them.
ANECDOTE

The "Blip" Misinterpretation

  • Determinists cite neuroscience tests showing brain activity (a "blip") preceding conscious decisions as evidence against free will.
  • However, these tests show weak correlation, not causation, and their authors didn't endorse deterministic conclusions.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app