A Pre-WWI French Philosopher Was More Popular Than Elvis and Possibly Entered the US Into the Great War
Dec 26, 2024
auto_awesome
Emily Herring, author of "Herald of a Restless World," dives into the extraordinary life of philosopher Henri Bergson. She reveals how his 1913 lecture created a frenzy in New York City, akin to rock star status. Herring discusses Bergson's role in persuading the U.S. to join World War I and how his ideas on creativity and freedom resonate in today's tech-driven society. The conversation highlights the decline of public philosophy and the need to revive Bergson's insights as we navigate modern challenges like AI and materialism.
Henri Bergson captivated early 20th-century audiences with his charismatic lectures, transforming philosophy into a popular cultural phenomenon.
Bergson's exploration of qualitative versus quantitative time provides a relevant philosophical perspective for navigating today's technological anxieties and human experiences.
Deep dives
Henri Bergson's Rise to Fame
In the early 20th century, Henri Bergson emerged as a prominent philosophical figure, captivating audiences with his lectures in France and the United States. His engaging speaking style and ability to communicate complex ideas in accessible language attracted large crowds, even leading to significant events like a traffic jam caused by attendees rushing to his lecture at Columbia University. Unlike his contemporaries, Bergson's charisma enabled him to reach beyond academic circles and appeal to the general public, effectively transforming philosophy into a cultural phenomenon. This unique connection with his audience contributed to his fame, marking him as a 'rock star' philosopher of his time.
Bergson's Impact on Intellectual Discourse
During the Belle Époque, Bergson's ideas resonated with the anxieties of a society grappling with the effects of mechanization and disenchantment brought on by scientific advancements. He asserted that philosophy should coexist with science, challenging the notion that empirical theories had the final say on understanding consciousness and time. Bergson posited that qualitative experiences of time and change were vital to comprehending reality, a perspective that diverged from the traditional views of his philosophical predecessors. His approach provided a hopeful lens through which people could navigate a rapidly changing world, fostering new interdisciplinary dialogues between philosophy and science.
The Tension Between Bergson and Einstein
Bergson’s philosophical exploration of time directly engaged with the contemporary scientific discourse exemplified by Albert Einstein’s theory of relativity. A famous interaction between the two revealed a fundamental misunderstanding, as Bergson argued for a qualitative understanding of time while Einstein maintained a more quantitative perspective. Their debate highlighted the friction between emerging scientific paradigms and philosophical inquiry, ultimately casting Bergson in a negative light among some intellectual circles. Despite this, Bergson remained deeply committed to scientific engagement throughout his career, demonstrating that his philosophical contributions were not anti-science, but rather aimed at enriching the dialogue between the two fields.
Bergson's Legacy and Modern Relevance
Although Bergson's popularity waned after World War I, his concepts are experiencing a resurgence in contemporary discussions about creativity, freedom, and the implications of technology on human existence. The parallels between 21st-century anxieties, such as the dehumanizing effects of algorithms and the longing for deeper experiences, echo the concerns Bergson raised in his lifetime. His emphasis on re-enchantment and the qualitative nature of time resonates in today's materialistic and data-driven society, making his ideas increasingly relevant. Advocates seek to revitalize his philosophies as frameworks for navigating modern challenges, suggesting a renewed interest in Bergson's thought as society grapples with its existential dilemmas.
In New York City, 1913, French philosopher Henri Bergson gave a lecture at Columbia University, resulting in fanfare, traffic jams, and even fainting spells among the thousands of people clamoring for a seat. But this was not Bergson’s only taste of celebrity. When he got married in 1891, Marcel Proust served as his best man. In 1917, the French government sent him to the United States to convince Woodrow Wilson to join World War I. In the early 1920s, he debated the nature of time with Albert Einstein. Once an international celebrity acclaimed for his philosophy of creativity and freedom in a changing, industrializing world, Bergson has since faded into obscurity among English speakers. But as we contend with another century of rapid technological advancements and environmental decay, Bergson’s philosophies may be more relevant today than ever before.
Now only known among scholars, French philosopher Henri Bergson achieved international fame in the years before World War I by inspiring a generation worried that new scientific discoveries had reduced human existence to a cold mechanical process. As new facial recognition and artificial intelligence technologies have us fearing for our freedom and humanity, we can find philosophical inspiration in a surprising source, by looking back to the thinker of radical change and creativity in the early 20th century.
Today’s guest is Emily Herring, author of “Herald of a Restless World: How Henri Bergson Brought Philosophy to the People.” It reminds us of an influential philosopher who deserves to be remembered as a both an icon of 20th century culture and an unexpected source of inspiration in turbulent times.