The Logical Case for Socialism (and Against Capitalism) w/ Scott Sehon
Aug 13, 2024
auto_awesome
In this engaging conversation, Scott Sehon, a philosophy professor at Bowdoin College and author of 'Socialism: A Logical Introduction', dives into the logical foundations of socialism. He critiques capitalism while discussing the philosophical paths that shaped his beliefs. The dialogue includes a fascinating analysis of moral arguments for socialism, the importance of rights in society, and the tension between reform and revolution. Sehon emphasizes the necessity of reasoned discourse and presents compelling cases for universal healthcare and equitable resource distribution.
The podcast highlights the irony that socialist arguments often contain more empirical support than those for capitalism, challenging common narratives.
Scott Sehon discusses the application of philosophical logic to critique capitalism and advocate for socialism as a superior economic system.
Evidence presented in the episode illustrates socialism's capacity to enhance human well-being compared to capitalism's often misleading claims of prosperity.
The conversation emphasizes the importance of democratic control in economic systems, suggesting that collective decision-making can lead to better societal outcomes.
Deep dives
Announcement of Live Podcast Recording
The episode begins with a brief announcement about a live podcast recording event featuring journalist Abby Martin in Los Angeles, in partnership with All Power Books. Listeners are invited to attend this event, with links provided for easy access to tickets. This sets the stage for the ensuing discussion while encouraging community engagement. The hosts express their enthusiasm for meeting listeners in person.
Debunking Right-Wing Narratives
The discussion centers around the right’s frequent claim that logic and reason are exclusive to their arguments, with notable figures like Ben Shapiro asserting that 'facts don’t care about your feelings.' The commentary highlights the irony that when both the left and right are examined critically, the evidence actually favors socialism over capitalism. Key arguments favoring socialism often include empirical data emphasizing equity, fairness, and demonstrable benefits of socialist policies. The hosts emphasize the importance of relying on logical reasoning grounded in factual data to counter misrepresentations of leftist ideologies.
The Logical Study of Socialism
The episode introduces Scott Sian, a professor of philosophy, who discusses his book 'Socialism, a Logical Introduction.' He explains that the philosophical study of logic can be applied rigorously to the arguments surrounding socialism and capitalism. The central aim is to uncover the logical premises that underlie economic systems and the relationship between reasoning, benefits, and moral implications. This sets a foundational understanding for evaluating socialism as a compelling alternative to capitalism rooted in logical analysis.
Evidencing the Superiority of Socialism
A significant part of the discussion involves presenting evidence supporting socialism's ability to enhance human well-being. The talk critiques the notion that capitalism inherently results in greater prosperity by pointing out that socialist experiments, particularly in some former Soviet-bloc countries, have led to improvements in various socio-economic metrics. This empirical data is contrasted against common capitalist narratives that suggest only capitalism fosters progress. The emphasis on scrutinizing both economic systems through a logical lens allows for a more nuanced conversation about real-world outcomes.
Public Goods and Market Failures
Monopoly, public goods, and negative externalities are identified as critical factors in the conversation about capitalism's shortcomings. The argument stresses that public goods, like education and healthcare, serve broader societal interests and therefore should not be treated solely as commodities. The failure of free markets to adequately manage resources and societal needs, especially in light of climate change, illustrates the inherent limitations of capitalism. Instead, embracing a more collective approach under socialism could help address these significant issues more effectively.
The Importance of Democratic Control
The potential benefits of increased democratic control over economic systems are examined. The conversation suggests that greater collective decision-making can lead to improved outcomes and overall well-being for citizens. By fostering a democratic approach within economic structures, the public has a say in decisions that profoundly impact their lives. This argument aligns with the push for more egalitarian and socially responsible economic practices reminiscent of Nordic models.
Conclusions: The Case for Socialism
The episode culminates with a call for a radical restructuring towards socialism, advocating for increased egalitarianism and collective control. The hosts argue that the logical framework outlined throughout the discussion supports a fundamental shift from capitalist structures. They emphasize that while the exact path forward is complex and requires nuanced policy considerations, the moral and empirical justification for socialism is sound. Ultimately, they assert that the tools of logic, reason, and evidence should guide the movement towards a more just and equitable society.
Facts don’t care about your feelings. Logic isn’t fair. Reason isn’t concerned with your emotions. These oft-regurgitated cliches hurled at the left by those on the right might sound familiar to you. Hey, maybe they’ve even been directed at you personally. And, aside from seeing these claims from the right as simply funny, they’re also quite ironic. Because, when you actually dig down into the arguments of both the left and the right, it becomes quite clear, quite quickly, that the facts are actually on our side. That when you use logic and reason to argue for either capitalism or socialism, it’s socialism that comes out as the winner. Everytime.
There are many tools in the left’s toolbox when it comes to convincing those we interact with about the superiority of socialism. We do have arguments that center on fairness and equity, on more feelings-based arguments, which are very compelling and which we should certainly not abandon. But we also have a vast arsenal of arguments that rely on simple logic. And it’s some of these arguments that we’re going to explore—both in favor of socialism and against capitalism—in this episode. And we’ve brought on the perfect guest to walk us through this style of argumentation.
Scott Sehon is a Professor of philosophy at Bowdoin College and author of the book Socialism: A Logical Introduction, published by Oxford University Press. In this episode, we introduce the philosophical study of logic and how to construct and deconstruct logical formulas and logical arguments. We then apply this knowledge to the real world by asking what is the better economic system: socialism or capitalism? In the process we discredit and overturn some of the most common arguments for capitalism, we explore what we actually mean by socialism and socialistic societies, we explore a great deal of empirical data suggesting the superiority of societies with more democratic control and more egalitarian distribution, and, we talk about the importance of utilizing the tools of logic and reason as socialists.
Upstream is a labor of love—we couldn't keep this project going without the generosity of our listeners and fans. Subscribe to our Patreon at patreon.com/upstreampodcast or please consider chipping in a one-time or recurring donation at www.upstreampodcast.org/support
If your organization wants to sponsor one of our upcoming documentaries, we have a number of sponsorship packages available. Find out more at upstreampodcast.org/sponsorship
