Azad Essa, "Hostile Homelands: The New Alliance Between India and Israel" (Pluto Press, 2023)
Dec 13, 2024
auto_awesome
In this engaging conversation, Azad Essa, an award-winning journalist, delves into the intricate alliance between India and Israel under Modi's leadership. He highlights how India's foreign policy has shifted, drawing parallels with Israel's settler-colonial approaches, especially in Kashmir. Essa explores the historical roots of this relationship, critiquing the intertwining ideologies of Hindutva and Zionism. He warns about the implications of these alliances on democracy and justice globally, underscoring the urgent need for awareness of these geopolitical shifts.
The transformative alliance between India and Israel under Modi reflects a concerning shift towards authoritarianism and ethnonationalism in both nations.
Historical ties between India and Israel, initially rooted in support for Palestine, have evolved into a complex military-industrial partnership since the 1990s.
The ideological parallels between Hindutva and Zionism raise alarms about the impact on democracy and self-determination for marginalized groups in both countries.
Deep dives
Deepening Alliance Between India and Israel
The episode discusses the evolving relationship between India and Israel under the leadership of Prime Minister Modi. It highlights how Hindu nationalism has increasingly mirrored Israeli practices, particularly regarding military and surveillance tactics. The alliance has transformed into a strategic partnership that extends beyond military cooperation to include ideological frameworks and control over minority populations. This critical examination reveals how both nations utilize similar political messaging and security strategies, influencing the regional political landscape.
Historical Context of India-Israel Relations
The conversation delves into the historical origins of the India-Israel relationship, tracing its roots back to colonial times prior to the independence of both nations. It emphasizes how initial support for Palestinian rights by figures like Gandhi and Nehru has paradoxically coexisted with military relations with Israel. The podcast also points out the strategic self-interests that have guided India’s foreign policy, leading to a reconfiguration of its stance towards Israel over the decades. As geopolitical dynamics shifted, India’s earlier narratives of supporting freedom in Palestine became increasingly complicated.
Military-Industrial Relationships
The episode discusses how the military relationship between India and Israel began clandestinely during the China-India war in the early 1960s. Nehru requested military assistance from Israel, initiating a long-term collaboration that would expand significantly in the 1990s. This partnership has led to deep knowledge sharing, involving not only weapons but also police and paramilitary training programs. The influence of Israeli military practices is evident in contemporary Indian policing, demonstrating the interconnectedness of their security strategies.
Ideological Parallels: Hindutva and Zionism
Listeners learn about the ideological similarities between Hindutva and Zionism, both of which utilize historical narratives to support their nationalistic agendas. The discussion highlights how both ideologies are rooted in a sense of civilizational superiority and utilize exclusionary practices to maintain dominance within their respective states. The leaders’ rhetoric reflects a belief that both nations have a historical right to claim particular territories while suppressing the rights of marginalized populations. This analysis prompts a reflection on how narratives of victimhood are manipulated to justify oppressive policies.
Democracy vs. Occupation: A Paradox
The podcast emphasizes the challenge of reconciling the democratic identities of both India and Israel with their roles as occupiers in Kashmir and Palestine, respectively. It critiques the notion that either state can be genuinely democratic while denying self-determination to significant portions of their populations. The discussion raises critical questions about the validity of democratic claims in light of systemic oppression faced by minorities. This examination contributes to a deeper understanding of democracy's complexities, especially in contexts marked by occupation and repression.
Under Narendra Modi, India has changed dramatically. As the world attempts to grapple with its trajectory towards authoritarianism and a 'Hindu Rashtra' (Hindu State), little attention has been paid to the linkages between Modi's India and the governments from which it has drawn inspiration, as well as military and technical support.
India once called Zionism racism, but, as Azad Essa argues, the state of Israel has increasingly become a cornerstone of India's foreign policy. Looking to replicate the 'ethnic state' in the image of Israel in policy and practice, the annexation of Kashmir increasingly resembles Israel's settler-colonial project of the occupied West Bank. The ideological and political linkages between the two states are alarming; their brands of ethnonationalism deeply intertwined.
Hostile Homelands: The New Alliance Between India and Israel (Pluto Press, 2023) puts India's relationship with Israel in its historical context, looking at the origins of Zionism and Hindutva; India's changing position on Palestine; and the countries' growing military-industrial relationship from the 1990s. Lucid and persuasive, Essa demonstrates that the India-Israel alliance spells significant consequences for democracy, the rule of law and justice worldwide.
Azad Essa is an award-winning journalist and author based between Johannesburg and New York City. He is currently a senior reporter for Middle East Eye covering American foreign policy, Islamophobia and race in the US. He is the author of The Moslems are Coming and Zuma's Bastard and has written for Al Jazeera, The Washington Post, Foreign Policy and the Guardian.
Stuti Roy has recently graduated with an MPhil in Modern South Asian Studies from the University of Oxford.