#STRask Do People with Dementia Have Free Will?
Jun 16, 2025
The discussion dives into whether individuals with dementia possess free will and moral responsibility for their actions. Philosophical and biblical insights unravel the complexities of accountability in cognitive decline. Anecdotes and scripture highlight the tension between harmful behaviors and compassion. The hosts explore how the Holy Spirit influences personal transformation amidst sin. Additionally, the podcast emphasizes self-reflection and character growth as vital elements during the aging process and in caregiving.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Rethinking 'Ought Implies Can'
- The moral principle 'ought implies can' suggests people aren't responsible if they can't do what is right.
- Leviticus challenges this by requiring sin offerings even for sins committed unknowingly.
Examples of Moral Capacity Limits
- Amy shared an infant's angry reaction as an example of behavior not morally responsible.
- Greg described a young man with a disability who was self-centered but could control impolite behavior when required.
Behavior Control in Disabled Youth
- Greg shared a story about a disabled young man who was self-centered and interruptive.
- He could behave politely when challenged, showing capacity for moral control despite limitations.
