Louder with Crowder Deport All Illegals | Change My Mind
4 snips
Nov 10, 2025 Savannah Walsh, a social work major from the University of Oklahoma, joins to debate immigration policy. The conversation kicks off with whether illegal immigration should be classified as a crime. They dive into current deportation practices, racial profiling concerns, and the complexities of defining who qualifies as illegal. Savannah challenges historical claims of stolen land, while Crowder argues about the economic impacts and crime rates associated with illegal immigration, advocating for English language and cultural assimilation expectations in a proposed compromise.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Economic Cost Of Illegal Immigration
- Steven Crowder argues illegal immigration imposes a net cost of $150–$450 billion annually on U.S. taxpayers.
- He claims deporting 20 million would cost about $350 billion once, producing net savings within ~1–2 years.
Definition Of 'Illegal'
- Crowder defines "illegal" simply as anyone present without paperwork, including visa overstays.
- He frames immigration as a legal binary: either lawful or not, with corresponding enforcement.
Stolen Land Challenge
- Savannah Walsh raises the stolen-land argument: "How can people be illegal on land that didn't belong to them?".
- She says she would not deport people except for extradition in criminal cases.